She was angry in earnest, and went on: " To succeed, a man must be resolute and bold. Lubkov is not so handsome as you are, but he is more interesting. He will always succeed with women because he's not like you; he's a man . . . ."
And there was actually a note of exasperation in her voice.
One day at supper she began saying, not address- ing, me that if she were a man she would not stag- nate in the country, but would travel, would spend the winter somewhere aboard—in Italy, for in- stance. Oh, Italy I At this point my father uncon- sciously poured oil on the flames; he began telling us at length about Italy, how splendid it was there, the exquisite scenery, the museums. Ariadne sud- denly conceived a burning desire to go to Italy. She positively brought her fist down on the table and her eyes flashed as she said: " I must go I "
After that came conversations every day about Italy: how splendid it would be in Italy— ah, Italy I — oh, Italy I And when Ariadne looked at me over her shoulder, from her cold and obstinate expres- sion I saw that in her dreams she had already con- quered Italy with all its salons, celebrated foreigners and tourists, and there was no holding her back now. I advised her to wait a little, to put off her tour for a year or two, but she frowned disdainfully and said: " You're as prudent as an old woman I " Lubkov was in favour of the tour. He said it could be done very cheaply, and he, too, would go to Italy and have a rest there from family life.
I behaved, I confess, as naively as a schoolboy. Not from jealousy, but from a foreboding of some- thing terrible and extraordinary, I tried as far as possible not to leave them alone together, and they made fun of me. For instance, when I went in they would pretend they had just been kissing one an- other, and so on.
But lo and behold, one fine morning, her plump, white-skinned brother, the spiritualist, made his ap- pearance and expressed his desire to speak to me alone.
He was a man without will; in spite of his educa- tion and his delicacy he could never resist reading another person's letter, if it lay before him on the table. And now he admitted that he had by chance read a letter of Lubkov's to Ariadne.
" From that letter I learned that she is very shortly going abroad. My dear fellow, I am very much upset I Explain it to me for goodness' sake. I can make nothing of it I "
As he said this he breathed hard, breathing straight in my face and smelling of boiled beef.
" Excuse me for revealing the secret of this let- ter to you, but you are Ariadne's friend, she respects you. Perhaps you know something of it. She wants to go away, but with whom? Mr. Lubkov is proposing to go with her. Excuse me, but this is very strange of Mr. Lubkov; he is a married man, he has children, and yet he is making a declaration of love; he is writing to Ariadne ' darling.' Excuse me, but it is so strange I "
I turned cold all over; my hands and feet went numb and I felt an ache in my chest, as if a three- cornered stone had been driven into it. Kotlovitch sank helplessly into an easy-chair, and his hands fell limply at his sides.
" What can I do? "I inquired.
" Persuade her. . . . Impress her mind. . . .
Just consider, what is Lubkov to her ? Is he a match for her? Oh, good God I How awful it is, how awful it is I " he went on, clutching his head. " She has had such splendid offers — Prince Maktuev and . . . and others. The prince adores her, and only last Wednesday week his late grandfather, Ilarion, declared positively that Ariadne would be his wife — positively I His grandfather Ilarion is dead, but he is a wonderfully intelligent person; we call up his spirit every day."
After this conversation I lay awake all night and thought of shooting myself. In the morning I wrote five letters and tore them all up. Then I sobbed in the barn. Then I took a sum of money from my father and set off for the Caucasus without saying good-bye.
Of course, a woman's a woman and a man's a man, but can all that be as simple in our day as it was before the Flood, and can it be that I, a culti- vated man endowed with a complex spiritual organ- isation, ought to explain the intense attraction I feel towards a woman simply by the fact that her bodily formation is different from mine ? Oh, how awful that would be I I want to believe that in his strug- gle with nature the genius of man has struggled with physical love too, as with an enemy, and that, if he has not conquered it, he has at least succeeded in tangling it in a net-work of illusions of brother- hood and love; and for me, at any rate, it is no longer a simple instinct of my animal nature as with a dog or a toad, but is real love, and every embfrace is spiritualised by a pure impulse of the heart and respect for the woman. In reality, a disgust for the animal instinct has been trained for ages in hundreds of generations; it is inherited by me in my blood and forms part of my nature, and if I poet- ize love, is not that as natural and inevitable in our day as my ears' not being able to move and my not being covered with fur? I fancy that's how the majority of civilised people look at it, so that the absence of the moral, poetical element in love is treated in these days as a phenomenon, as a sign of atavism; they say it is a symptom of degeneracy, of many forms of insanity. It is true that, in poetizing love, we assume in those we love qualities that are lacking in them, and that is a source of continual mis- takes and continual miseries for us. But to my thinking it is better, even so; that is, it is better to suffer than to find complacency on the basis of woman being woman and man being man.
In Tiflis I received a letter from my father. He wrote that Ariadne Grigoryevna had on such a day gone abroad, intending to spend the whole winter away. A month later I returned home. It was by now autumn. Every week Ariadne sent my father extremely interesting letters on scented paper, writ- ten in an excellent literary style. It is my opinion that every woman can be a writer. Ariadne de- scribed in great detail how it had not been easy for her to make it up with her aunt and induce the lat- ter to give her a thousand roubles for the journey, and what a long time she had spent in Moscow try- ing to find an old lady, a distant relation, in order to persuade her to go with her. Such a profusion of detail suggested fiction, and I realised, of course, that she had no chaperon with her.
Soon afterwards I, too, had a letter from her, also scented and literary. She wrote that she had missed me, missed my beautiful, intelligent, loving eyes. She reproached me affectionately for wast- ing my youth, for stagnating in the country when I might, like her, be living in paradise under the palms, breathing the fragrance of the orange-trees. And she signed herself " Your forsaken Ariadne." Two days later came another letter in the same style, signed " Your forgotten Ariadne." My mind was confused. I loved her passionately, I dreamed of her every night, and then this " your forsaken," " your forgotten "— what did it mean ? What was it for? And then the dreariness of the country, the long evenings, the disquieting thoughts of Lubkov. . . • The uncertainty tortured me, and poisoned my days and nights; it became unendurable. I could not bear it and went abroad.
Ariadne summoned me to Abbazzia. I arrived there on a bright warm day after rain; the rain-drops were still hanging on the trees and glistening on the huge, barrack-like dependance where Ariadne and Lubkov were living.