Frank Abbott sighed.
“Well, we’d better go on. You got to the door, and you found it open-”
“Unlatched,” said Lucy Craddock. “And I thought how strange it was, and I went in and shut it after me as quietly as I could because of Mr. Pyne-he sleeps so badly, you know, and always complains that he hears every sound.”
“Well, on the one occasion when he might usefully have heard something, he seems to have slept all night. Will you go on, Miss Craddock?”
“I began to go upstairs. The light was on in the hall as usual, but all the landing lights were out. I thought that was very strange indeed.”
“You didn’t put the lights on?”
“No, I went up in the dark. I thought I would put on the light when I came to my own landing. You see, I had given the key of my flat to Lee Fenton, so I knew I should have to ring and wake her up.”
“And did you?”
“No.” She sank back against the cushions and clasped her hands again. She said in slow, halting sentences, “I had to find the switch. It is on the wall by the door of Ross’s flat. I was feeling for it when I pushed the door and felt it move. I remembered the front door being open, and I was very frightened. It didn’t seem to me to be at all right. I opened the door a little way, and there was a light coming from the sitting-room. I called out, and I said, ‘Ross, are you there?’ ”
Her voice quavered in the telling, as it must surely have quavered when she stood in the dark and called to the man who lay dead in the room beyond. She drew a long breath and went on.
“I thought I ought to see if everything was all right. I went into the hall. The sitting-room door was standing wide open. From where I stood I could see a broken wine glass lying on the floor. There was a horrible smell of spirits and-and gunpowder. I thought about fireworks-and then I thought Ross wouldn’t. And then I began to be very, very frightened indeed. I felt as if I must go in, but I was so dreadfully afraid. I had to go in. I was sure something dreadful had happened. I saw Ross lying on the floor-with a pistol in his hand-”
“Miss Craddock, are you sure about that?”
Lucy Craddock began to cry.
“Oh, yes-he was dead-he was quite dead. I saw him-lying there.”
“Miss Craddock, please. You said just now that the revolver was in his hand.”
“Oh, yes-it was.”
“Are you quite sure about that? You know, when the body was discovered the revolver was lying some way off.”
Lucy Craddock’s eyes opened till they looked quite round.
“But I saw it in his hand-and I thought, ‘He has shot himself.’ And then I thought, ‘But why is this door open, and why is the street door open?’ And I thought, ‘No, he’s been murdered, and they’ve tried to make it look like suicide-because that is what Jasper Crosby did in Crimson Crime.’ So I am quite sure about the pistol, Mr. Abbott, and if it wasn’t there when he was found, then somebody must have moved it afterwards, because he was-oh dear!-quite dead.”
“Somebody moved it,” said Frank Abbott. “And somebody took care to confuse any fingerprints there might have been.”
He looked at Peter Renshaw, and Peter looked back. There was an infinitesimal pause. Then Abbott said,
“Will you tell us what you did next, Miss Craddock?”
“I ran away,” said Lucy Craddock simply. “I ran out of the house and down the street. I ran until I couldn’t run any more, and then I didn’t know where I was. It took me a long time to get to Phoebe’s, but at last I did. And then I fainted.”
Frank Abbott leaned forward.
“Why didn’t you alarm the house?” he said.
Lucy Craddock stared at him. Her chin began to tremble.
“Why didn’t you rouse the house? You say you thought your cousin had been murdered. You must have more than suspected that you had just seen the murderer. Miss Fenton and Peter were both within call. Why didn’t you call them?”
She went on staring.
“I-I couldn’t.”
“Why couldn’t you? Miss Fenton-Peter-both within call-your own flat waiting for you-why should you run out into the street and wander there for an hour? Why, Miss Craddock?”
She said in a dry whisper,
“I-I was so frightened.”
“But you ran way from the people who could have helped you. Miss Craddock, you must have had a reason for running away like that. Shall I tell you what I think that reason was?”
Lucy Craddock said, “No-no.”
Abbott went on speaking in his quiet, pleasant voice.
“It was something you saw that sent you running out of the house-I think it was someone you saw.”
She gasped, and got breath enough to speak firmly.
“No, no, Mr. Abbott, I didn’t see anyone-only poor Ross, and he was dead.”
He watched her face.
“You didn’t see your niece, Miss Mavis Grey?”
“Oh, no, Mr. Abbott.”
“Or Miss Fenton?”
A look of simple surprise answered this before she said in a tone of relief,
“Oh, no, not Lee.”
“Or-Peter?”
The relief was still in her voice.
“Oh dear, no.”
“Miss Craddock, whom did you see?”
“I didn’t see anyone-I didn’t indeed.”
“You saw something that sent you running out into the road. Won’t you tell me what you saw? It was something to do with your niece, wasn’t it-with Mavis Grey?” He saw her face quiver. “You see, we know she had been there.”
She turned at that to Peter, and he said,
“They know that Mavis came back with Ross. He frightened her, and she came over to me at one in the morning. Miss Bingham saw her. Ross was alive then. Miss Bingham, fortunately, saw him too.”
Abbott struck in.
“Miss Craddock, you are not helping your niece by holding anything back. A full statement might help her very much, because, you see, she returned to Craddock’s flat at three o’clock. Miss Bingham saw her when she was coming back. Miss Grey foolishly denies this second visit and refuses to explain it. But if you saw Ross Craddock dead at a quarter past two, don’t you see how important that is to your niece? My idea is that she went back to the flat at three o’clock because she had left something there.”
“Her bag,” said Peter. “She said she had dropped it on the landing. You know, Fug, she couldn’t have expected to find Ross’s front door open.”
“She may have had a key.”
“I don’t think so. If she had, it would be in her bag. She had that bag at the Ducks and Drakes, and she didn’t have it when she came over to me at one o’clock, but it was in her hand when she came back at three.”
“She didn’t tell you where she had been?”
“She told me she had dropped the bag on the landing.”
“Did you believe her?”
“No.”
“Was Craddock’s door shut-then-when she came back to your flat?”
“The landing was dark-I suppose Miss Bingham told you that-and I never left my hall, so I don’t know whether Ross’s door was open or shut. It was shut first thing in the morning.”
This rapid interchange of question and answer seemed to pass Lucy Craddock by. When it ceased she said,
“I see what you mean, Mr. Abbott. Indeed that is why I wished to make a statement. If poor Ross had been shot before Mavis went back to that dreadful room to look for her bag at three, then no one could suspect her of having anything to do with it.”
“She did go back for her bag then?”
Lucy Craddock looked at him nervously.
“Perhaps I ought not to have said that, but, as I told her, it is our duty to help the law, and he was dead long before she came into the room.”
“And it was her bag that you saw, Miss Craddock. Was that it? Was that why you didn’t give the alarm?”
“Oh, no, Mr. Abbott. I didn’t see the bag at all. I wouldn’t have left it there if I had seen it. Oh, no, it had slipped down behind the cushion in that big chair, and I never saw it at all.”