The next letter was on stiff paper and typed.
“From old Prothero-
‘Dear Mr. Craddock,
In pursuance of our conversation on the morning of the tenth instant, I would beg to urge upon you very seriously the necessity of providing against an intestacy. The unsettled property which passed to you under your mother’s will has so greatly appreciated in value on the termination of the long-term leases granted by her grandfather, the late Mr. Margetson Ross, that I cannot believe that you will any longer delay to make testamentary dispositions of what amounts to a considerable fortune.
Yours sincerely,
Thos. Prothero.’
“Old Prothero says Ross really was going to play. The conversation, I gather, was all about Aggie, and good nippy things like-did he really want her to scoop the lot if he walked under a bus on his way home, or words to that effect. Prothero is shaken to the core at the idea of old Margetson Ross’s unearned increment going into Aggie Crouch’s pocket. Well now, to proceed… There are two or three more letters from Prothero about the falling in of those leases-and that’s all here.”
The second tray held quite a number of letters put up in small bundles and neatly docketed-Ada; Stella; Pat; Linda; Ninon; Marie.
Peter whistled softly.
“Bit of a lad Ross-wasn’t he? I don’t really think these can have anything to do with the affair, but you never can tell.”
“There won’t be anything there,” said Lee wearily. “How can there be? If someone shot Ross to get back some letter or paper, well, they wouldn’t come away without it, would they?”
“I don’t know,” said Peter. “They might if they were frightened-or disturbed. But anyhow that wasn’t what I had in my mind.”
“What did you have?”
“I don’t quite know,” he said.
There seemed to be nothing of importance in the letters. Ninon wrote in French, and Ada could not spell. Stella was frankly out for a good time and as much money as she could get. Pat had finished on a blazing row. The date was the year before last-and a great deal of water flows under that sort of bridge in eighteen months. Linda used the pathetic stop, and it was noticeable that only two of her letters had been preserved. Pathos wouldn’t go at all well with Ross.
Peter dropped the packets back.
“As you say, nothing there. And the rest are just business things by the look of them.”
But under the business papers a final packet came to light, quite unbelievably labelled “Miss Bingham.” Peter stared at it incredulously.
“Darling, am I seeing things, or does this docket say what I think it does?”
“It says, ‘Miss Bingham,’ ” said Lee, looking over his shoulder.
“Gosh!” said Peter.
He removed the rubber band. There were three letters. He unfolded the first and read aloud:
“ ‘Dear Mr. Craddock,
I really fail to understand your letter. I am no gossip, but I conceive that I am entitled to my own opinion.
I remain yours truly,
Wilhelmina Blngham.’ ”
The date was June 15th of the current year. “This,” said Peter, “is highly intriguing. What had Miss Bingham been no gossip about?”
“Mavis and Ross, I should think,” said Lee.
“We have now a second letter dated June the twentieth.
“ ‘Dear Mr. Craddock,
I am quite at a loss to understand your tone. I have never received such a letter in my life, and I shall most certainly consult my solicitor. I do not know what you mean by talking about slander. I am sure I have never said anything but the truth, and if that is an offence it is not my fault.
Yours truly,
Wilhelmina Bingham.’ ”
“She was beginning to get rattled. And here, in number three… Oh Lord, I think-yes, I’m sure she must have been to her solicitor. Listen to this!
‘Dear Mr. Craddock,
I much regret that any remarks of mine should have been reported to you as reflecting upon your character, or on that of any other member of a family with which I have been on terms of close friendship for years. Since you desire me to say so in writing, I acknowledge that I was misinformed. I regret the words attributed to me-you do not tell me who your informant was-and I hereby tender you a sincere apology for anything I may have said. I hope that you will be satisfied with this, and that you will now relinquish any idea of taking legal proceedings.
Yours truly,
Wilhelmina Bingham.’ ”
“I wonder what she said,” said Lee.
Peter laughed.
“I think one can guess. I begin to have some respect for Ross. Well, I’m afraid I don’t think she would have gone the length of shooting him to get these letters back.”
Lee said “No-” in a doubtful voice, then turned on him with sudden passion.
“Peter, it’s horrible! We’re all suspecting each other-we’re ready to suspect anyone! A thing like this puts the clock back about a million years, and we’re all in the jungle again with everyone’s hand against everyone else. I should be glad if it were Miss Bingham, and so would you. Doesn’t it show what this has done to us already? She’s never done us any harm.”
“Speak for yourself, darling,” said Peter coolly. “Personally, I consider her a menace-Wilhelmina the Unwanted.”
Lee steadied herself, gulped, and said,
“Sorry, Peter. I didn’t mean to do that. What are you going to do with the letters-tear them up or give them back to her?”
Peter grinned.
“Which do you think she’d like least? She must be wondering about them, you know. I might ring her up and say, ‘Fly! All is discovered.’ Or I might write a polite little note beginning, ‘Dear Miss Bingham-’ ”
Lee grabbed his arm and pinched it severely. With her left hand she pointed at the door. It was opening slowly. Round the edge of it appeared Miss Bingham’s fuzzy fringe, her marked dark eyebrows, her firm red cheeks, and her jutting upper lip. The sharp eyes darted their inquisitive glances at Lee with her hand on Peter’s arm, at Peter and the open despatch-case with its tumbled papers. She showed all her teeth in an ingratiating smile and said brightly,
“The outer door was ajar, and, do you know, I thought I heard my name. I hope I don’t intrude.”
Lee pinched again, because she was so dreadfully afraid that Peter was going to say “You do.” She said hurriedly,
“Oh, no, of course-we were just sorting some papers.”
“Oh, yes-naturally. So nice of you to help, Mr. Renshaw. But don’t you find it very trying-a great strain? The very room in which such a shocking crime took place. But perhaps you are not psychic. All the Binghams are intensely psychic. My grandmother, who was a Bingham of the younger branch and married her cousin-dear me, what was I saying? Oh! Why, Mr. Renshaw-are not those my letters? I-yes, surely!”
She had arrived at the table, and with the last word pounced on the three letters which were lying where Peter had thrown them down. He laughed a little and said,
“Did you come to fetch them?”
Her eyes darted maliciously at him. Her fingers began to fold and unfold the sheets of stiff, old-fashioned paper.
Peter said, “Is this the first time you have come for them, Miss Bingham?”
“I don’t know what you mean, Mr. Renshaw.”
“Sure you don’t?”
“I don’t know what you are talking about.” She began to tear the letters across and across, and across again, her hands moving so fast that it was done almost before they had known what she was going to do. “I am really quite at a loss”-it was the phrase she had used in one of those torn letters-“quite, quite at a loss. Mr. Craddock and I were on perfectly friendly terms until someone made mischief-and if this is a free country I cannot see why one is not entitled to one’s own opinion!” Her voice trembled with anger. Her hands trembled so much that the torn fragments she was holding fell from them and strewed the floor. “And so I told my solicitor, but he wouldn’t listen to me-a most disagreeable man. And he made me write what I consider an extremely humiliating letter, Mr. Renshaw, which is now, I am pleased to say, torn up. And I won’t disturb you any longer, Miss Fenton. You seemed to be very busy indeed when I came in. I can see when I’m not wanted, I can assure you.”