Teddy sat on the floor of the boathouse, leaning against the wall and trying to compose himself. ADA Carolyn Powell was kneeling before him, overwrought with disbelief and suspicion, and holding a flyer that included the victim’s picture in her hand. Apparently, the girl’s name was Valerie Kram and she’d been missing since mid-October.
Powell narrowed her eyes and told him to say it again. Teddy had shown her where he found the body and recounted his story six or seven times over the last three hours. Every time Powell got off the phone, she wanted more.
“I don’t know what happened,” he said. “Until yesterday, I was working on a personal injury case. I had an appointment with someone. I came down here, but she didn’t show.”
“And what?” Powell shot back. “You walked into the boathouse and found another body. Valerie Kram. Just like that.”
Teddy gave her a look, knowing his story sounded preposterous. “Just like that,” he said.
The medical examiner was working on the body ten feet away and well within earshot. “We don’t know who this is yet,” he said.
Powell ignored him, her eyes still drilling Teddy. Everyone in the room seemed to know who it was.
“The missing persons unit has been looking for Valerie Kram for six weeks,” Powell said. “You found her in what, a half hour?”
Teddy remained quiet, his eyes drifting back to the body. It struck him that Valerie Kram looked remarkably similar to Darlene Lewis. They were roughly the same age. They shared the same coloring and overall style. The implications seemed ominous.
Powell stood up, clipping her cell phone to her belt. “The treasurer of the boat club is Fred Bingle,” she said. “But his wife doesn’t work for an insurance company and he doesn’t know what you’re talking about. Her name’s not Dawn, it’s Doris, and she’s a housewife. Capital Insurance Life has no record of an employee by that name either. The phone number you gave us isn’t even part of a cellular network. It belongs to a dot com company that hit the skids two months ago.”
He didn’t say anything. He knew that he’d been set up the moment he found the body. He knew that he’d been led here to find it, and that the Holmes murder case was no longer what it seemed.
“This is bullshit,” Powell said. “You’re gonna need a better story, Teddy.”
District Attorney Alan Andrews was standing with Detective Vega and his partner, Nathan Ellwood, watching the ME cut the tube top away from Valerie Kram’s body with a pair of scissors. But the district attorney was shifting his weight and fidgeting. Once Teddy had pulled himself together, he’d made the call to Powell on his cell phone. She notified Vega and Ellwood, but a dispatcher had made the mistake of using the radio to reach the ME rather than a land line. The press had overheard the conversation, and were waiting for Andrews outside in force. Andrews was still angry about it and looked edgy enough to snap.
“Forget about the kid,” he said to Powell. “He made a mistake. A big one. He’s trying to cover his tracks and it’s not working very well.”
“What are you talking about?” she said.
Andrews turned. He had a smile going now and appeared mean as his eyes locked on Teddy’s.
“There’s only one way he could’ve found the body,” Andrews said. “And that’s if Holmes told him where he’d left it. Nice work, Teddy Mack. You want a job with the prosecution team, just say the word. Either way your client’s a dead man.”
Powell moved closer. “Is that what happened, Teddy? Did Oscar Holmes tell you where the body was?”
Teddy lowered his eyes, trying to hide his anger and surprise and the feeling that the situation had a life of its own he couldn’t control. He hadn’t thought about the next step. He hadn’t considered what the scene might look like to others when he called for help. He heard Andrews snicker, then watched the man return to the corpse. The ME had removed the cloth and was examining the wound down the girl’s chest. It was long and deep, all the way through but still somewhat frozen. Unlike Darlene Lewis, none of her skin appeared to be missing.
“One thing’s certain,” the ME said. “You guys need to adjust your time line.”
“Why?” Andrews asked.
“If this is Valerie Kram, then she turned up missing in October.”
“It’s Valerie Kram,” Andrews said. “Her face matches the picture. She was last seen jogging on the bike path. So what?”
“This girl hasn’t been dead for more than a week or two.”
Andrews snapped to attention, then knelt down for a closer look at the body.
“The water would’ve been relatively warm in October,” the ME said to him. “Once she went into the river, she was part of the food chain. Fish. Turtles. You get the idea. And she’s swollen, but not bloated. Most of her hair’s intact. Her flesh is still clinging to her bones. If she’d been in the water for two months, she wouldn’t resemble that picture any more. Not by a long shot. What was left of her would look and feel like Jell-O.”
The ME pinched the dead girl’s skin, trying to make his point.
Teddy turned away, glancing at the crime scene techs roaming through the building as he thought it over. Not many women jogged in a tube top. And if he could trust what he’d just heard, then Valerie Kram probably hadn’t been murdered here or anywhere near Boathouse Row. The murderer had picked her up somewhere along the bike path. He’d taken her away and kept her for more than a month, then dumped her in the river when he was through with her. If the rope holding the corpse to the bottom had held, no one would’ve ever found her. But that didn’t seem very important right now. What stood out for Teddy was the time the murderer spent with the girl. The place he held her. The dread in his gut that Holmes might be responsible for a second young woman’s death.
“I’m gonna schedule of double autopsy,” the ME said. “Her and Darlene Lewis.”
“When?” Andrews asked sarcastically. “Next week?”
“Tomorrow,” the ME said, ignoring the spike and turning to his assistant. “Let’s bag this up and get her out of here.”
Teddy rose to his feet and stretched. Outside the window he could see the press crowding behind the crime scene tape that had been strung along the trees on Kelly Drive. He turned back to the room. When Powell broke away from Andrews, he pulled her aside.
“I want the keys to Holmes’s apartment,” he said.
She gave him a suspicious look. “Why?”
“Because he’s my client.”
“It’s still under seal,” she said, turning away as if she had something more important to do.
“I have a right,” he said. “I want the keys.”
She turned back, studying his face and thinking it over. Teddy held the glance.
“You’ll need an escort,” she said after a moment. “Someone from the office. The keys are in my desk. I’ll give you a call in the morning.”
“I want to go tonight,” he said. “Now.”
She was sizing him up again. “What are you up to, Teddy? What haven’t you told us?”
“Nothing,” he said. “I want to look at my client’s apartment.”
“I’ll have someone meet you there in twenty minutes.”
She walked off. Teddy spotted Andrews standing before a mirror in the hall. The man was whispering something to himself. After a moment, Andrews began experimenting with different smiles and various shades of compassion as if he were alone. When he found what seemed like the appropriate facial expression, the district attorney vanished through the lobby and out the door ready to meet the press. Teddy waited a beat before following him outside.
The night air had a bite to it. And the afternoon mist had thickened into a rich wet fog. He saw Andrews waving his hands as the press gathered around and camera lights were switched on. Teddy started up the bike path, then stopped and turned to watch once he reached the shadows. He noticed the boathouses were lit up. The small white lights outlining the buildings were part of the festive nature of the city and burned every night of the year. They looked like Christmas trees. Only tonight didn’t seem particularly festive, and the holidays felt like maybe they ought to be postponed.