Hunter arched an eyebrow and took a few steps towards his partner.
‘I got this from an old storage room in Gardena High.’ He handed Hunter the photo.
‘Storage room?’
Garcia quickly summarized his day at Gardena High before stabbing at the picture with his index finger. ‘Second girl from the left.’
Hunter studied the girl Garcia had indicated. It didn’t take him long. ‘Amanda Reilly,’ he said confidently.
‘That’s right.’ Garcia retrieved an old-fashioned, Sherlock Holmes-style magnifying glass from his desk and handed it to Hunter. ‘But that’s not all. Take a look at the last girl on the right, the one who has a sort of amused look on her face.’
Hunter analyzed the picture once again, this time for a while longer. There was nothing peculiar about the girl, and he was about to ask Garcia ‘What about her?’ when he saw it and stopped.
‘You’re kidding me?’
‘Looks familiar?’ Garcia said, arching his eyebrows.
Hunter turned to the picture board and unpinned the woman’s photo they’d found on the fireplace inside the Malibu mansion. The one with the number two written on the back. He brought it back to his desk and sat it next to the schoolgirls’ photo. His eyes jumped from one picture to the other several times before he looked at Garcia. ‘It’s her.’
Garcia nodded slowly. ‘That’s what I thought, but I didn’t have that photo with me.’ He pointed to the woman’s picture on Hunter’s desk. ‘I needed to come back here to confirm it. Now I’m positive. They went to the same school, Robert. Amanda and the alleged second victim hung out together.’
‘What’s her name? Who is she?’
‘That, I still don’t know.’
‘Did you get a yearbook?’
Garcia told him about the stolen yearbooks and the burned down printer. ‘The school might have a graduating picture, but I’m not sure. As I said, I needed to first confirm my suspicion, and by the time I got out of the storage room everyone was gone. Today was the last day for the faculty. The school is closed for the holidays.’ Garcia returned to his desk. ‘If they have a graduating picture and it hasn’t been stolen, it will probably be in the library.’
‘Won’t this Mr. Davis have the keys?’
‘Probably, but I wouldn’t know where to start. Their library is massive. I would’ve ended up just wasting time. We need the librarian or someone who works there, and as of today they’re all on vacation.’
Hunter thought it over. ‘OK, let’s try and get back in contact with the school principal or anyone who might know where to find these graduating pictures.’ He glanced at the girls’ photograph. ‘Two out of four girls on that picture are dead. The other two are probably in great danger. We need to find them, and we need to find them fast.’
Clang. The office door slammed shut with a thundering noise, making both detectives turn around. Captain Blake was standing inside the room. She looked furious.
‘What the fuck do you two think you’re doing?’ The question was spat out between clenched teeth.
Eighty-Three
Both detectives frowned as they exchanged puzzled looks before facing the captain.
‘Are you sure you’re yelling at the right detectives, captain?’ Hunter answered, cocking his eyebrows.
Captain Blake’s piercing gaze focused on him. ‘Are you sure you wanna get cute with me today, Robert?’
Hunter straightened his body. ‘Captain, we were out all day. I have no idea what you’re talking about.’ He looked at Garcia.
‘Me neither.’ Garcia shook his head, his stare jumping from Hunter to Captain Blake.
‘Would you care to explain?’ Hunter said calmly.
‘I thought I’d made myself clear about you going after that psychic girl, if that’s what she is.’
Hunter’s confused look intensified. ‘Did she call?’
‘How the hell would I know that? Do I look like your personal answering service?’
Hunter glanced at Garcia, who was staring at the captain wide-eyed. ‘Maybe you should get to the point before that bulging vein on your forehead pops, captain. We still don’t know what this is all about.’
‘Did you see the paper today?’
Garcia shook his head. Hunter held a blank stare.
‘Oh, I forgot. You don’t read the paper ’cos it depresses you, isn’t that what you said?’
Hunter was in no mood to carry on with the irony game. ‘What’s in the paper, captain?’
‘The two of you – front page.’ Captain Blake slammed the copy of the LA Times she had with her on Hunter’s desk. The paper was folded in half. A black and white photograph of Hunter and Garcia sitting at an outside table in the company of a young woman occupied a quarter of the page. Hunter snatched the paper. Garcia joined him by his desk, trying to read the article over Hunter’s shoulder. The girl in the picture was Mollie Woods.
Hunter read the small article in silence. It went on to explain how detectives Robert Hunter and Carlos Garcia of the HSS were so stuck for leads in their investigation into the murders of Father Fabian and Amanda Reilly that they had to resort to asking for the help of a psychic girl. The article had been written by Claire Anderson.
‘Bitch,’ Hunter murmured.
Garcia grabbed the paper from Hunter when he was done.
‘You went behind my back on this,’ the captain said angrily.
‘We were just talking to her, captain, listening to what she had to say. That’s what we do in investigations, remember? We talk to people, we ask around.’
‘According to that article, you asked her to help with the investigation. Did you do that?’
No reply.
‘Without clearing it with your superior officer? In this case, me.’ The captain stood with her hands on her hips.
Hunter ran a hand over his face and breathed out. ‘It’s psychology, captain.’
‘What?’
‘She was nervous, hesitant. I had to make her feel at ease and unthreatened. By telling her that we needed her help I shifted the power balance.’
‘So you did ask her for her help?’ the captain pressed.
‘It was a play on words to get her to talk to us, captain. I’m the lead detective in this investigation. I did what I thought I should do. That’s how I work.’
‘Hold on.’ Captain Blake lifted a hand, stopping Hunter and glaring at him. ‘Did you just throw a title at me? You’re the lead detective in this investigation because I said so, a decision I’m starting to regret. We’ve now become the laughing stock of LA’s law-enforcement agencies. The article called us the mystic police, Robert. The tarot cops.’ She paused, and her stare bounced between Hunter and Garcia for a while. ‘No surprise the mayor’s been on the phone screaming like a lunatic, and he’s now accusing me of being unable to run this department properly. He said I lack authority, unlike my predecessor. Do you know how much that pissed me off?’ She didn’t wait for a reply. ‘He’s on a crusade to get you busted down to traffic duty if not off the force for good, and let me tell you, he’s gaining momentum.’ She started pacing the room. ‘I told you I wanted this to go by the book. That if you found this girl, you were to bring her here. She needed to be interviewed under caution and I wanted to observe.’
Hunter rubbed his eyes and leaned against his desk. ‘She was scared, captain,’ he said slowly. ‘She wanted to talk, but not here. She felt nervous in the interrogation room. She wanted to meet in a public place.’
‘So you disobeyed my order because that’s what she wanted?’
‘I had to make a decision, captain,’ he replied firmly. ‘Go by the book or hear what she had to say. We couldn’t have both.’
‘How the fuck did the paper get to know what we talked about?’ Garcia asked. ‘High-powered directional mikes?’