She smeared the juice all over the big hard knob, making it gleam and Jim moaned hoarsely. More big hot globs of juice bubbled from his cock cleft, and Cindy scooped it up with her fingers, smelled it, and tasted it. Now she understood why Mrs. Dolan liked to lick up her husband's prick juice.
"Mmmmmmm," she sighed.
Jim was flattered that she liked to touch and taste his cock, but right now he had more urgent things on his mind. His bloated young balls felt ready to explode with their hot load, and his prick was achingly stiff. All he could think about was last night and how Cindy had let him fuck her, or rather, try to fuck her. He prayed she'd let him do it again.
"Cindy, honey, please," he moaned, "I wanta fuck you so bad."
Cindy could have gone on happily playing with his cock for a long time, but she heard the urgency in his voice. Well, she could play with him later. It was more important to get rid of her damned virginity, to finally find out what it was like to fuck. Obediently she stretched out on her back and opened her legs wide, bending her knees.
"Okay, Jim," she said, "let's fuck."
Jim groaned, hardly believing his luck. He'd been trying to get into Cindy's pants for months now, but she'd always said no. He didn't think he'd ever score with her, and now, overnight, she was hot to trot. He recovered from his surprise, felt the horny ache in his rigid young prick, and quickly crawled between her invitingly spread legs.
Jim's hard hairless chest met Cindy's stiff little nipples, and his wiry bush pressed her soft springy muff. She felt him stuffing his rock-hard prick between her thighs, and his throbbing cock, sawed deliciously over her swollen, wet pussy. He poked around, trying to find her cunt hole, and at last he wedged the big bulbous head of his cock into the buttery hollow.
"Awwwwwww, Christ," Jim panted.
This was just where they'd been interrupted last night, his bloated cock-head stuffed about an inch into Cindy's virgin cunt. It seemed huge to her, and she thought her elastic pussy would tear, but to her relief the fleshy ring expanded and took the hard hot knob. Jim caught his breath, gave a horny grunt and pushed.
"Uhhhhh," Cindy gasped.
"Ohhhhh, man!" Jim moaned.
Her virgin cunt was incredibly tight, and he'd been able to plow his rigid cock only another inch inside her. Cindy felt like somebody was trying to shove a cannonball up her cunt. But she'd heard that it always hurt a girl the first time, and she tried to be brave. She had to know what fucking was like, even if it hurt. Jim grunted and shoved again.
"Ooowwwwwww!" Cindy wailed.
He had half his steely six-inch prick into her now, and she was sure it would split her in half. She couldn't hold back her tears. Jim raised himself on his elbows and looked at her worriedly.
"Is it hurting you pretty bad?" he asked.
Cindy nodded tearfully and added, "But don't stop, Jim. I just have to know what it's like."
Jim breathed a sigh of relief. It would have damned near killed him to take his bloated cock out of her deliciously tight pussy-hole before he had a chance to come. He could feel the gripping walls of her virgin cunt, scorching hot and wet with juice. He wanted to sink his cock all the way into that snug little tunnel. He took a deep breath and plowed into her again.
"Unnnggghh!" Cindy groaned.
That did it, he was all the way in. As he paused for breath, panting and sweating from the effort of breaking her cherry, Cindy could feel his rock-hard prick stuffing every inch of her bruised cunt. She could feel his knobby cock-head touching her womb, his big wiry-furred balls resting against her slit. She wasn't a virgin any more, but she didn't know how she felt about it.
"You got it, baby," Jim panted. "You got every fuckin' inch of my cock."
"I… I feel it," Cindy whimpered.
That was putting it mildly. She felt like her tender pussy was impaled on a baseball bat. Catching his breath, Jim started fucking into her, going slowly and gently so as not to hurt her. What he really wanted to do was cram his aching prick into her hard and fast, but he sensed that his gentleness would pay off. Cindy gasped and dug her nails into his shoulders.
"I'm fucking you now, baby!" he moaned. "How does it feel?"
"Fine," Cindy lied.
It hurt, and it was scary, but she wasn't going to chicken out now, not when they'd gone so far. Each slow deep lunge of Jim's thick throbbing cock scraped and bruised her tiny tight cunt, but as he went on fucking her, she started to get little twinges of pleasure every time he stuffed her. She started to relax, and her pussy began to cream.
"Ahhhhh, fantastic," Jim panted. "You got such a nice tight pussy, Cindy."
No shit, she thought sadly. She would have given anything if it weren't so tight. Jim's cock sawed steadily in and out of her tender little fuck-hole, and she felt a strange mixture of pain and excitement. She remembered Mrs. Dolan's ecstasy as Mr. Dolan crammed his huge cock into her like a pile driver, and she wondered if she'd ever be able to take a fucking like that.
But Jim's slow gentle fucking was finally getting results. The more she relaxed and creamed, the more her cunt expanded to take his plowing cock, and the more slick and juicy it got. The little twinges of pleasure changed into hot blasts of sensation, and to her astonishment, Cindy found herself actually wanting more speed and force.
"Ahhhbhhh, yeah, Jim," she moaned. "It's starting to feel really good now. Do it harder."
Jim moaned with relief. It was killing him to restrain the plowing of his cock in that deliciously tight hot cunt. He speeded up the tempo of his fucking, and Cindy, responded with a gasp of pleasure and a big hot rush of cunt juice that drenched his cock.
"Unnnnnhhhh, yesss," she whined. "Fuck me, Jim honey, fuck me hard!"
Now she could understand why Mrs. Dolan had gotten so wildly aroused from her husband's savage-looking fucking. The faster and harder Jim fucked her, the better it felt. She was getting so excited, she couldn't stay still any longer. She began jerking her hips in an instinctive fucking motion, meeting his stiff lunges with a greedy downward thrust of her heavily juicing pussy.
"Ohhhhh, I love it," she whimpered. "I just love the way you're fucking me, Jim."
Jim almost shot his load just listening to her. It was exciting enough that his formerly prudish girl friend had actually agreed to fuck, and it was even more exciting to find her pussy so incredibly tight. But it really blew his mind when she used those dirty words to tell him how much she loved his fucking.
She was wriggling and writhing so lustily now that he had to shove his hands under her churning little ass and grip the hot globes to hold her in place. Again he speeded up his fucking and gave it to her harder. Cindy moaned in ecstasy and soaked his prick with another flood of steaming pussy juice. She fucked right back at him, slamming her slick cunt up and down the rigid spike of his cock.
"Ahhhhh!" she wailed.
It had been worth all the pain. Her cunt was still a little bruised and sore, but she hardly noticed it as took the steady deep plowing of her boyfriend's cock. Each hard lunge stuffed her cunt deliciously and sent a bomb blast of pleasure ripping through her pussy. Already she knew she was hooked on fucking for the rest of her life.
"Is it okay for you, Cindy?" Jim panted.
Was he kidding? Couldn't he tell she was going out of her mind with lusty excitement?
"Mmmmmmm Jim, I love it," she moaned. "Fuck me, honey! Fuck!"
His rigid cock was sawing back and forth over her swollen clit giving her additional blasts of pleasure before it plunged deep into her burning wet fuck-hole. Cindy clawed his sweaty shoulders and whimpered in ecstasy. She was creaming so heavily that the steaming syrup overflowed her cunt and gushed down the crack of her ass. The pleasure built in her pussy till she could hardly stand it.