Our relationship was no-strings-attached, purely physical. The first night we hooked up, we did it in her pool house.
This pool house made Andy’s basement look about as tricked out as a grass hut, and I wasted no time bragging about it to Luke. When Caitlyn texted me that she was going to Cabo with her family for winter break and she’d have to cancel our plans, I joked with Luke that we should go to her house anyway. He talked Andy and his brother into going too, because we had nothing better to do, so the four of us headed over.
We didn’t intend to take anything that first time, just hang out. I’d seen Caitlyn punch in the door combination for the pool house, and I tried it—making sure my hand was in the sleeve of my jacket so I didn’t leave fingerprints. Once inside we weren’t that careful. We drank the six-pack we’d brought with us and watched a skin flick while the guys pushed for details of my hookups with Caitlyn. All in all a pretty boring night, and at some point, it felt wrong. We were about to leave when Luke suggested we make the visit worth our while by swiping some stuff.
Andy and his brother were stoked by the idea, which I didn’t get, because they already owned half the stuff anyway. We ended up taking a small flat-screen TV. The whole time I felt detached, not really participating but not stopping them either. We left without the headlights on and tore down the street, pumped up with adrenaline from doing something so stupid. We stopped at a White Castle on the way home and didn’t talk about it again.
Until Caitlyn got back from break and wanted to show me her tan lines.
“Dude, you have to see her again. Show her you’re not afraid of going there—you’re not guilty of anything,” Luke said, almost making me believe it was true.
My nerves were on edge when I saw Caitlyn, but it was same old, same old. We hung out in the pool house. The TV we’d taken had been replaced by a bigger model. There was no mention of anything that had happened while she’d been away. I left that night, promising to call her, but I knew I wouldn’t. I changed my number the next day. And I never saw her again.
That was when the seed was planted. Hadn’t it worked out great? We didn’t even need to break in, Luke said. If we could do this . . . find a way to get in without being obvious, get to know the lay of the land, find out when a family would be there and when they wouldn’t . . . It was too perfect. I told him I thought we’d just been lucky. He said he was going to prove me wrong.
And he did. Swiping a gold necklace that he sold for the equivalent of five of my term papers. Our Amsterdam fund was born, but if we were really going to make a go of it, Luke said, we needed to get smarter.
We didn’t use our real names or personal cell phones, just in case there was a slipup. Logan and Dev, our lacrosse teammates, each wanted in, so then we were six. At first we took turns finding hits, but soon enough our talents sorted us out. Luke and I were best at finding the right mark. Andy, Dev, and Logan swiped the stuff. Andy’s brother unloaded it.
The selling part was a bit trickier. Andy’s brother dealt with the electronic stuff, the ones with serial numbers, the stuff that could be traced. Gold was a cinch to sell—Luke found a guy through Spiro willing to take our stuff, no questions asked. Deep down I knew what we were doing was wrong, but since I wasn’t physically stealing anything and was directly involved with only two or three hits, I could kid myself that I wasn’t a thief. I was only doing my part for the team. And with each successful job, we became more confident. Cocky. We were gods, on and off the lacrosse field.
Occasionally someone’s conscience would bubble up, but Luke was fantastic at talking anyone down from the ledge of I want out. We weren’t robbing people blind. Just lifting stuff here and there. GPS systems, iPods, jewelry people probably didn’t even wear anymore. Extra stuff, easily replaceable.
And we ate it up, all of us, the feeling of being . . . invincible.
So walking into Andy’s on that Thursday afternoon felt a bit like stepping back in time. Andy’s brother had moved on to Seton Hall, but the rest were assembled as always. Logan and Dev were planted on the futon playing Black Ops on the wide-screen. Andy had headphones on, strumming his guitar. Luke was sitting behind the bar, to-go cup of coffee in one hand, The Life of Pi in the other. I could picture myself there too, walking in with a sack of burritos from Taco Bell, setting up my laptop, writing my term papers, running my business. All separate parts of a whole. Would it be that easy to fall into it again?
Then I saw my drums. Or, more specifically, my bass drum, with a huge tear. Andy pulled off his headphones when he saw me.
“Grayson, sorry about the drum, man. Things got out of hand. Some chick put her heel through it. Accident.”
“Accident,” I repeated as I knelt down to assess the damage.
“Yeah, wouldn’t have happened if you’d stayed at the party,” Luke said. I stood up and turned to him; he was still reading. He used a drink stirrer to mark the page, closed the book, and placed it on the bar next to his coffee.
“Nah, probably would have happened anyways. Things were pretty outta control when I left,” I said, breaking down my kit.
“Grayson, why the rush? Hang out awhile, man,” Andy said.
“Yeah, hang out,” Luke said, hands in pockets.
Logan and Dev came up behind me. I stood up with the feeling I was about to get jumped . . . mentally, at least.
“What?” I asked.
They all just stared at me. Finally Logan spoke.
“Gray, you gotta come back. It hasn’t been the same without you around.”
“We’re sorry about, you know, not calling—” Dev began.
“But really, dude, if the great Grayson Barrett could get caught, what chance did we have?” Andy finished.
“Like it or not, you’re the proverbial glue that holds us together, Grayson,” Luke said.
If I’d heard this speech six months ago, I would have fallen into step again. Now it seemed contrived. Getting kicked out of school for selling term papers was humiliating enough, but I was picking up the pieces, working my way through it. Getting caught for the Operation Amsterdam stuff would be damaging beyond anything these idiots would be prepared for. I may have missed St. Gabe’s, but I was not willing to go back to the way things were. I’d broken free of the cave and the shadows on the wall. Maybe I wasn’t too much of a hedonist for The Republic to sink in after all.
“You’re doing fine without me,” I said.
“Maybe we are,” Luke said, “but we’re expanding a bit.”
“Yeah, my brother’s got a lock on apartments at school, an easy hit,” Andy said.
“And none of us can score the best hits like you, Gray,” Logan said.
“Well, except maybe for me, but I’m just one. Strength in numbers,” Luke said, putting a hand on my shoulder.
I returned to breaking down my kit, silent, but their questions and pleas swirled in the air around me.
“I’m rusty,” I said. It was all Luke needed to hear.
“Dude, please. It’s like riding a bike. Easy. Remember that hit you were working on, the chick from Hollister in Staten Island? Pick up with that again. You’ll be back in the swing of it in no time.”
Allegra.
“No, don’t think so,” I said.
Luke smirked and pulled out his phone. My stomach sank as he scrolled through his contacts and lifted the phone to his ear.
“What are you doing?”
His eyes were planted on mine.
“Hi, can I speak to Wren, please?”
I charged toward him, reaching for the phone, but he spun his back to me, moving away. Logan and Dev grabbed my arms. I squirmed against their hold, but four months without so much as lifting a five-pound barbell and I was no match for them. Only Andy appeared shocked at what was happening.