‘We’ve worked together, yes,“ Master Naylor answered, and then, as if he had been asked for an explanation, ”He’s Lord Lovell’s bailiff for Prior Byfield.“
Seemingly introducing her to Master Spencer was another courtesy being bypassed, and Frevisse raised her head to see what passed between the men as Master Naylor nodded greeting to the other man with, “Master Spencer. I hadn’t thought to see you again before Michaelmas.”
Master Spencer returned the nod but only barely and looked away to Domina Elisabeth who said as if doing a thing she did not want to, “He’s come from Lord Lovell with a problem concerning you, Master Naylor.”
Master Naylor looked between the two of them with a trace of surprise on his usually unrevealing face. “A problem?”
‘It seems Lord Lovell has had report that possibly you’re a villein of his,“ Domina Elisabeth said.
In the sudden gap of silence then, Frevisse was aware of the soft cooing of doves around the well in the courtyard below the open window, the warm shift of air across her face as a corner of the day’s light wind found its way into the room, the distant clop of horses being led across cobbles in the outer yard, until slowly, as if finding his way to the words, Master Naylor said, “What am I to answer to that except to say it isn’t true?”
‘You could, if it’s true, admit it,“ Domina Elisabeth said, as carefully as he’d asked it, ”because clearly you’ve had far more than your fugitive year from him and are free, even if you were born bond.“
Master Naylor looked at Master Spencer. “In this case, that wouldn’t serve, would it? Lord Lovell always pursues his rights to any villein that flees.”
‘He would have entered his claim to you into the courts when you first fled, yes,“ Master Spencer agreed. And under law, that gave Lord Lovell right to claim his property no matter how long a time had passed.
‘Except I was never his villein,“ Master Naylor said.
‘That will have to be proven.“ Master Spencer turned from him to Domina Elisabeth. ”You understand that with his skills and abilities, Naylor is valuable enough for my lord to pursue this in hope of having him back.“
Frevisse noted that Master Spencer had already reduced Master Naylor to only Naylor, as without title as he would be without freedom if Lord Lovell’s claim were proved true.
‘And there are his wife and children, too,“ Master Spencer went on.
Frevisse saw Master Naylor’s hands clench into fists at his sides, his first overt sign of anger and not for himself but for his family, threatened because a person’s freedom or unfreedom were determined not only by their parentage but by their birthplace. If Master Naylor was proved to have been born unfree, then even if his wife was freeborn, their children would be unfree like their father, Lord Lovell’s property along with him, unless it was shown they had been born on freehold land, and Frevisse knew for certain that at least some of them had been born here in St. Frideswide’s priory that was not freehold. So if Master Naylor were proved villein born and his children born here, they could only be free if their mother was freeborn and not married to their father. But that would leave them bastards.
Tense with in-held anger, Master Naylor said, “My wife is freeborn. And my children. And me.”
Not looking at him but somewhere into the air over Domina Elisabeth’s shoulder, Master Spencer answered, “I promise you I’m no more pleased with this than you are, Naylor, but we both have to see it through, that’s all.”
‘Then,“ said Domina Elisabeth curtly, ”you might begin by continuing to call him Master Naylor until it’s proven otherwise against him. Who made this accusation?“
‘That isn’t something I’m free to say,“ Master Spencer answered. ”Someone saw him and recognized…“
“Thought they recognized,” Frevisse put in with a curt-ness that matched Domina Elisabeth’s.
‘Thought they recognized him,“ Master Spencer said stiffly, giving her a sharp, resenting glance, ”and rightly sent word to Lord Lovell of it.“
By St. Benedict’s Rule, the nunnery was required to take in as guests any travellers who asked for hospitality. It could have been anyone among those who had stayed in the guesthalls, here for only a night or two in passing, through the past few weeks, who had seen Master Naylor and thought they knew him and felt duty bound to tell Lord Lovell. Unless Master Spencer chose to tell them, they had no way of guessing who it had been, and likely who it had been did not really matter. The hurt was done and would have to be dealt with, whoever had caused it, Frevisse thought, while Master Spencer went on, “What I’ve come for, besides to tell you of it, is to insure he doesn’t have chance to run again while this is sorted out.”
‘I can’t run ’again,‘ “ Master Naylor said grimly, ”not having ever run at all.“
Except for a sideways flinch of his eyes, Master Spencer ignored that. “Because he’s potentially so valuable to his grace, I’m here to take him into my keeping, to see him to Minster Lovell, where he can be held safe, since bringing it to court will take time.”
‘No,“ Domina Elisabeth said with flat certainty.
Momentarily off-balanced by so utter a refusal, Master Spencer stared at her, then recovered his place and dignity, drew himself up, and started, “I fear I have to insist…”
‘No,“ Domina Elisabeth repeated, her certainty unabated. ”You will not take Master Naylor into your keeping or anywhere away from here. Considering how much it is in Lord Lovell’s interest to find him unfree, I can’t think it advisable to put him in your power.“
‘Madam!“ Master Spencer rose to outrage. ”I promise you his grace…“
‘Is Lord Lovell bound by promises you make in his name?“ Domina Elisabeth asked.
Master Spencer paused, tried, “If Naylor…”
Domina Elisabeth raised a hand in warning to him.
He colored. “If Master Naylor should run…”
‘St. Frideswide’s will undertake that he will not,“ Domina Elisabeth said.
But Master Spencer had found what looked to him to be firm ground. “If it’s proven, madam, that he’s Lord Lovell’s villein and in the meantime you’ve let him flee, I pray you consider that the priory will be liable for Lord Lovell’s loss of him. Would St. Frideswide’s be able to make good the loss and pay the penalties for it?”
Knowing as full well as Frevisse did that the answer to that was no, Domina Elisabeth skirted direct response with, “He won’t be left free to run. I’ll see to his being kept in his own house under watch while this is sorted out.”
‘Watched by whom?“ Master Spencer asked. ”They’re all men who’ve worked under him. How good a watch can they be trusted to keep?“
Domina Elisabeth smiled at him pleasantly. “You’re welcome, of course, to leave men of your own here to watch as well.” And added before he could answer that, “I’ll of course also be writing to Abbot Gilberd of St. Bartholomew’s in Northampton for advice.”
As only a priory, St. Frideswide’s affairs were perforce overseen by an abbey that by right had final say in all its business but in practice mostly left the nuns to manage themselves. Only the disaster their last prioress had made of things had brought Abbot Gilberd directly into their affairs and allowed him to appoint their new prioress, rather than let them elect their own as was usual. He had chosen his sister, and now she invoked him as a reminder to Master Spencer that he had not only her to deal with, a “mere” woman, supposing he harbored any such fool’s notion regarding women, which he shouldn’t from what Frevisse knew of Lady Lovell, and it was with a touch of caution that he ventured in answer, “I see no reason why, under guard, Master Naylor can’t stay here. With men of mine to guard him along with yours.”