‘He looked dreadfully ill, but his spirit was as stubborn as ever,’ said de Alençon to his friend. ‘I don’t know if as a true Christian I should believe or reject these notions of the supernatural, but I suspect that there are few in Exeter who believe that his recent afflictions were not the work of Lucy’s curse!’
De Wolfe agreed that in court that day the canon had looked in bad shape. ‘His stroke seems to have healed, but his affliction of boils seems worse. What was the outcome?’
‘Like your account of the sheriff’s dismissal, John, it was short, though by no means sweet. The bishop allowed him to remain seated owing to his parlous state of health, but that was the only concession he made. He roundly condemned him for excessive zeal, which he said was grossly misplaced.’
The coroner drank and set down his cup. ‘Yet at the start the bishop seemed Gilbert’s staunch ally in his crusade against these cunning women. How could he turn around so completely?’
‘I’m sure his brother gave him a good talking-to, when he visited. Though to the people at the cathedral the bishop is only one step down from God Almighty, to William the Marshal he is just a younger brother!’ The priest wiped the sweat from his brow, the atmosphere seeming to press in on them, before continuing. ‘Though no one knows what was said between them in private, I suspect that William offered very robust opinions on Henry’s covert support for Prince John, as well as about his aligning himself with crooked sheriffs and dangerously obsessive canons!’
A large drop of water plopped on to the table between them, followed by another. Looking up, John saw that the roiling clouds were moving across the darkening sky, the large moon appearing in the gaps and then disappearing again.
‘Best go inside, John, the heavens may empty on us in a moment.’
They moved indoors, and sat in the archdeacon’s study, a three-branched candlestick on the table between them.
‘So what happened to Gilbert?’ persisted the coroner.
‘Henry Marshal upbraided him for being too gullible in accepting the unproven accusations of those who denounced the various women. He blamed him for persuading the parish priests to give inflammatory sermons, encouraging unruly mobs and inciting riots which ended in the deaths of two citizens.’
‘What did de Bosco say to this?’
‘He fought back valiantly, but the bishop hardly let him speak. At one point I feared he might call the proctor’s men over to shut him up! Endless denials, rambling excuses and an attempt to justify his great crusade seemed to be his object, but his speech was not that clear and, as I say, the bishop rode roughshod over him.’
There was a long rumble of thunder outside and they could hear the patter of rain beginning to fall outside the window.
‘You had better stay here a while, John — in this, you’ll be soaked just crossing the Close,’ said de Alençon, kindly.
‘If you’ve more of this particular wine, I’ll gladly stay all night,’ replied the coroner with a grin, the first he’d managed that day. As his cup was refilled from a jug, he continued his quest for news. ‘So what was the outcome? He deserves to be hanged, but that never happens to those of your cloth!’
‘No, we don’t go that far, thank God. At the end of it, Henry Marshal delivered a homily for our benefit, as well as for Gilbert, on the perils of taking anything to extremes. He paid lip-service to Gilbert’s good intentions in safeguarding the Holy Church, but condemned him for not seeking support and advice from wiser and cooler-headed counsellors.’
‘That’s bloody hypocrisy, considering that he strongly encouraged the man at the start,’ growled de Wolfe.
‘That’s as maybe, but the upshot of it was that he deprived him of his several prebends, so he has no living to support him or his vicar, and he is therefore no longer a canon of Exeter Cathedral, which means that he will lose his lodging in the Close. He applied no other penalty or stricture, but said that he would send Gilbert as priest to some remote parish in the diocese, where he would have time and space to reflect on his misplaced zeal and to pray for forgiveness for the damage he has caused.’
The coroner grunted in disgust. ‘So he gets away with having caused at least four deaths and goes off to sit in the sun in the countryside for a few years! As I said, he should have been hanged, like the poor women he betrayed!’
‘That would never happen, given benefit of clergy. And don’t think de Bosco saw it as an easy forfeit, John. When the bishop announced his decision, he howled like a dog and began raving about injustice. But Henry just motioned to the proctors and left the room. Gilbert was hustled away by them, still ranting at his unfair treatment and accusing everyone of conspiring against him.’
There was a flash which lit up the bars of the shutters on the window and, a short moment later, a loud clap of thunder.
‘At least this will cool the air — though the farmers and peasants will not welcome yet more rain on the harvest,’ observed the archdeacon.
‘So where is de Bosco now? It’s too much to hope that they locked him up until he’s banished to a mean chapel on Bodmin Moor or somewhere equally dismal.’
John de Alençon shook his head, the pink skin of his sunburned tonsure glistening in the candlelight.
‘They took him home and called the infirmarian to attend to his carbuncle and to cool his mania with a sedating draught. We look after our own, John, even if they have fallen by the wayside.’
As another peal of thunder shook the house, the archdeacon’s steward tapped on the door and put his head around it. ‘Pardon, sirs, but there’s someone who wishes to speak urgently with you. It’s Peter de Bologne, the vicar to Canon de Bosco.’
He stood aside and the young priest who had appeared at the inquest hurried in, rain dripping from his dark hair and shoulders. ‘Archdeacon, please, can you come? My master is behaving in a most strange manner. I fear for his safety.’
The two Johns rose and went to the door, which opened on to Canons’ Row. The huge towers of the cathedral rose in front of them, the dark bulk of the building black against the last of the western twilight. It was sheeting with rain, which fell almost vertically, with little wind to deviate it.
‘This way, he’s at the end of the Close. He’ll catch his death in this, given his state of health.’
The vicar hurried anxiously away, looking back to see whether they followed. The archdeacon looked at the coroner and shrugged. ‘Not much choice, have we?’
His steward tried to offer him a cloak, but he waved it away. ‘Better that only my cassock is soaked, rather than that as well. Come on, John.’
They both set off in the gloom, trotting through the downpour after the younger cleric. A hundred paces away, they passed de Bosco’s house, but the vicar kept going until he reached the foot of the city wall at the end of the Close. The fortification, which stretched all around Exeter, was about twenty feet high here, with a walkway along the top, reached by stairs built into the masonry at intervals.
At the foot of the nearest, the vicar stopped and pointed upward. ‘He went up there — I fear he must be confused in his mind, with the fever from the infection in those awful boils.’
The rain eased a little; it had seemed impossible that it could continue with such intensity for long. De Wolfe shook the water from his beetling eyebrows and began to climb the slippery steps. At the top, he looked right and left, then gazed down, to where the two priests were following him.
‘To the right, Crowner,’ called the vicar. ‘I saw him go towards the South Gate’
The wall here was a long uninterrupted stretch that overlooked Southernhay, the gardens and fields immediately outside the city on that side. It ended against the large bulk of one of the towers of the South Gate, which housed the burgesses’s gaol.