We know what Ben meant, have come across deer at the edges of woods, along thickets — the pulse visible in their necks. Animals that will either bolt when seen or stand so still they can be right in front of you and remain unnoticed.
The morning unfolds like any other: we watch Jane get dressed, watch her eat toast and cheddar leaning against the counter in her yellow kitchen. Together we listen to the BBC news on the radio: flood warnings in the east, economic crisis in the west, a group of miners stranded underground in a country so distant some of us have never heard of it. “They have sent up a note,” the man being interviewed says. “We are drilling air holes, there is reason for hope.”
Six weeks ago Gareth came back from his meeting with the Minister of Culture, called the senior staff into his office and announced that the museum would be closing. We turned to Jane to see what that might mean. Until that point, we believed we were still learning who we might be: following Jane like a pack of hounds, staring at the files she read, the objects she held, sometimes saying, “I know this!” Our days were spent huddling around astrolabes, stuffed tortoises, samplers, mustard pots, surgical tools, old diaries, photographs of estate lawns we might once have walked across. Some of us went back to the same objects again and again — a set of pearl hair combs, a galvanizing machine, the glass case of hummingbirds in the entry hall — stuttering toward our own names, sounds we thought might be familiar. But then Gareth gave everyone the news and a kind of panic set in.
For years we had been trying to mimic what we had seen Jane do with the museum collections: to catalogue, list and cite ourselves. We endeavoured to keep track of each other, tried to pay attention to who thought what. Most days this proved difficult. We have little in common: some of us are old, some young; the places or times we lived in feel different. And since we have no names to go by, we resort to epithets: The One with the Soft Voice, The Poet, The Musician, The Theologian, The One Who Sucks on His Teeth, The One Who Never Speaks, The Boy, The Girl, Cat, The Idiot. And then there are the transients, the passersby and the passers-through.
When remembering what documents or objects we’d circled or what things in the museum we’d returned to proved difficult, we braved philosophy. When that didn’t work, we began our interrogations, asking each other quick sets of questions to try to find even a stitch of memory to build on. What food did you like? What do you see when I say “green”? What clothes can you imagine yourself wearing? Who did you love? What noises surround you? What is your name? The answers, if they come at all, come slowly or in the form of further questions: progress in circles. We keep at it even though some of us are easily frustrated, some tired, sad or mean; even though some of us do nothing but run around the flat after Sam, barking like otherworldly animals.
Still, for those of us who want to make sense of things, there is constant learning. Time may have swept past us but we are caught in its gusting: we read the papers, watch the telly, listen in on conversations in cafés and tube stations, stand outside strangers’ windows observing them as they eat alone in the quiet burrow of their thoughts. Some of us have even gone to school, studied particular jobs, ridden in ambulances; one spends nights following vagrants as they tread from the city’s edge into the local park. In this way we have learned new words and new ideas, although the knowledge we gain is sometimes woolly. One of us can describe the spark that lit the universe, another knows clock workings, another listens to opera, one loves cowboy films, another the art of flower arranging. We understand the principles of radio waves and motors and satellite relays, even if we cannot say exactly how such phenomena operate. Meanwhile our own knowledge is lost or buried, our hands emptied of their work; even the accents that once shaped our mouths have been smoothed like stones scuttled on the banks of a whisking river.
We do not know what will happen when the Chester closes. Ask us what shape certainty takes and we will all point to a different corner of the museum: to the pendulum of the longcase clock, to the black stones of the birds’ eyes, to the teacups in the upper gallery, to books, locks of hair, dress silk, to the computer in Jane’s office, or the cabinet of milkweed and wild strawberry glass models made in a factory between wars. We do not know how to recover our histories, to identify what or whom we loved. We cannot see ourselves except as loose human forms — like those caught moving down the street in the museum’s early Victorian photographs, figures whose blurred shapes become clearer the longer you look at them. We only know that we are drawn to certain objects, places and people, and that we are bound to Jane like the Thale butterflies in the natural history hall — pinned to the boards in their long glass cases.
The sun is out when Jane leaves the flat to walk the three blocks to the tube station. It glints off the stand of bicycles, glides over the pastry shop window. At the end of the street we turn and follow Jane down the steps of the Underground through the short stretch of semi-darkness that divides the daylight above and the fluorescent light below. We feel a sense of having done this before every time, though we are uncertain whether this sense comes from the repetition of the act itself or an echo from some other conveyance in our lives.
Below ground the station is crowded, and wedged together we shuffle onto the train, using the doors because even though they are unnecessary to us, they are a convention we remember. Once settled, some of us read the papers over people’s shoulders, others watch the flares of tunnel light sweep past the windows. The boy amongst us flits the laces of a young girl’s shoe; the poet sways in the aisle, caught up in a daydream. All of us aware of each other the way you are after becoming accustomed to a dark room. After all, every presence has a kind of weight, something felt: moods and shifts and feelings, a steady pulse of being.
Jane has found a seat in the middle of the carriage between a young man playing a game on his mobile and a tourist with a backpack wedged between his knees. There is a woman in front of them holding on to the rail, a plastic bag that smells of the apricots and peaches within it swinging from her wrist. We notice all of this but Jane does not. She is staring at the floor trying to imagine what exactly will happen when she and William meet.
When she is quiet like this, when her thoughts are steady, we can follow them almost the same way we do when we will ourselves into her dreams. It’s like being in a valley in winter: the sound of a branch snapping, the shish of an icicle plummeting from a tree, amplified. This is why we’re here: because Jane thinks about us almost as much as she thinks about herself, because the distance between her life and ours is not as great as with others and because we are lost and Jane is the closest thing we’ve got to a map. And she is a good archivist, has a willingness to navigate history, to consider its blank pages. But history is tricky. Jane thinks it is a buffer, a static place that sits obediently between now and then — something she can pass through, the way people walk through the natural history hall or the upper galleries of the Chester Museum. But we know she is wrong, and we feel bad about that. History is shifty; it looks out for itself, moves when you least expect it.
3
The last time William Eliot touched Jane they were standing in a field in Yorkshire at a gate that marked the start of the Farrington botanical trail. He’d placed his left hand lightly on the back of her bare neck, an adult innocently guiding his daughter’s sitter through a passageway. It was 1991, and Jane was fifteen years old and wearing a blue fluted summer dress and new black ankle-strap shoes that she worried would be scuffed by the end of the walk. She was trying to catch a glimpse of the estate house that sat adjacent to the woods, craning her neck toward a gap in the hedge, when William said, “Come on, this way, we can walk by Inglewood House later,” his cool fingertips suddenly grazing her hot skin. She can still feel it sometimes: the light press of his thumb in her hairline, his body ghosting behind her.