“You could do some of your witchery for me, so that I might put a noose around your neck and rid this city of you for good.”
“And failing that?” Ethan said.
“Hutchinson wants a word with you.”
The sheriff started walking northward toward the center of the city. Ethan had little choice but to follow.
Lieutenant Governor Thomas Hutchinson, chief justice of the province, was the one man in Boston with whom Ethan was even less eager to speak than Greenleaf. Their previous encounters, especially those that occurred back when Ethan was inquiring into the death of Abner Berson’s daughter, had been unpleasant to say the least. Hutchinson was a difficult man tasked with an onerous job: administrating a city and province whose citizens had grown increasingly resentful of their colonial masters.
“Do you know what he wants?” Ethan asked at length, as they made their way through Cornhill.
Greenleaf regarded him briefly but didn’t reply.
The Town House, where Hutchinson and other provincial officials had their offices, was one of the most impressive structures in the city. Constructed of red brick, it had a graceful steeple, fine statues of a lion and unicorn on either side of its gable, and elaborately carved facings around its famous clock. It had long been one of Ethan’s favorite buildings, despite the fact that most every time he entered it and ascended its marble stairway to the second floor, he found himself in some sort of trouble.
Greenleaf led him to the door of Hutchinson’s courtroom and knocked once. At a summons from within they both entered.
Ethan had first met Thomas Hutchinson three years earlier, also in this chamber. The night before their initial encounter, Hutchinson’s home had been destroyed by a mob of Stamp Act agitators. Hutchinson, a tall, slight man, who sat with his back straight and his shoulders thrust back, had not changed much in the intervening years. There were a few more lines on his high forehead and at the corners of his mouth, but otherwise he hadn’t conceded much to age. He had a long, prominent nose, and he wore a powdered wig of curls that framed his face, giving him a slightly feminine aspect. He was dressed in a black suit and white silk shirt and cravat, as he had been the last time they met in these chambers. That summer morning in 1765 it had been clear that the previous night had taken its toll on him. His large dark eyes had been bloodshot, his skin blotchy. He didn’t appear to be in much better spirits on this day.
“Mister Kaille,” he said. “It’s been some time.” He turned his gaze to Greenleaf. “Thank you, Sheriff.”
Greenleaf left them.
“Do you know why I’ve summoned you here?” the lieutenant governor asked.
“I have some idea, yes,” Ethan said. “I would imagine you wish to speak with me of the Graystone and her men.”
Hutchinson regarded him, his lips pursed a bit. “Yes, that’s right,” he said at last. “To be honest, I wish that we might have found some other manner in which to investigate this devilry. But I can see why Mister Brower recommended that we involve you, and I know as well why Governor Bernard agreed, despite his misgivings.”
“Yes, sir.”
“I don’t understand much of what Brower told me about you. But I gather that you’re a witch, and that it was witchcraft that killed General Gage’s men aboard the Graystone.”
Ethan could have throttled Brower for telling Hutchinson that he was a conjurer.
“You have nothing to say?” the lieutenant governor asked.
“No, sir. I can help you find this killer; I may be the one person in Boston who is best equipped to do so. I don’t believe anything else matters.”
Hutchinson’s smile was as thin as a blade. “I admire your confidence, misplaced though it may be. You seem to have misunderstood me, however. Some of the others seem to think as you do. But I find myself agreeing with Sheriff Greenleaf. He believes that far from being the best person to solve these murders, you’re much more likely to be the person who committed them.”
“That’s ridiculous,” Ethan said, his stomach tightening. It didn’t surprise him to learn that the sheriff thought him guilty of such a crime, but having Greenleaf believe this was one thing. Having the lieutenant governor and chief justice of the province believe it was quite another. “Why would I have killed those men? And why after doing so would I agree to help investigate their murders?”
“Fine questions. I have no answer for you. And to be honest, I have no time to deal with such puzzles now. In case you hadn’t noticed, Boston is about to welcome over a thousand new residents-all in uniform-with several thousand more on the way.”
“All the more reason to leave the investigation to me, Your Honor, just as Mister Brower and Lieutenant Senhouse intended.”
“Yes,” Hutchinson said. The word itself seemed to taste bitter on his tongue. “It shouldn’t surprise you to hear that I have a different solution in mind.”
He was almost afraid to ask. “What solution is that?”
“You have to understand, I have nothing against you personally. And I have no desire to return to the barbarities of the last century. But it seems to me that those who governed this colony before Governor Bernard and myself were so horrified by events in Salem and Ipswich, and even here in Boston, that they grew complacent over the years. I believe that they-that all of us-have become too tolerant of your kind.”
“Tolerant,” Ethan repeated. “You believe people in Boston are tolerant of conjurers?”
“You’re alive, Mister Kaille. And apparently a number of people know what you are and have known for some time. As I understand it, there are others like you. An African woman who lives on the Neck. An older man on Hillier’s Lane. And others.”
Janna. And old Gavin Black. Ethan wasn’t sure what others Hutchinson meant, but he was as certain as he could be that most if not all of them had no more to do with the killing of the Graystone’s soldiers than had Janna or Black.
“You see my point,” Hutchinson said. “There are so many of you now, and any one of you could be responsible for these atrocities.”
“I had nothing to do with the attack on the Graystone. Neither did Janna or Gavin.”
“So you say. But nearly one hundred of His Majesty’s men are dead, and I haven’t the luxury of your certainty. I can’t take the time to find the one witch among you who did this. And since you’re all abominations in the eyes of God, I feel that I would be perfectly justified in purging all of you from the city. I don’t relish the idea of public hangings or burnings, but I’d be a fool if I didn’t also acknowledge that such a display might prove useful as the occupation proceeds.”
“You truly are considering this,” Ethan said.
“Of course I am. This occupation will begin in a matter of days, and I don’t want this inquiry of yours hanging over us indefinitely.”
“I don’t want that either, Your Honor. I assure you it won’t take that long. Give me ten days and I will have your murderer. I swear it.”
Hutchinson shook his head. “Ten days? That’s out of the question. I can give you five.”
“That may not be enough time,” Ethan said.
“Then perhaps I should have the sheriff arrest you and your witch friends straightaway.”
Ethan glared at him. “You do understand that limiting my inquiry in this way makes it more likely to fail.”
“I disagree,” Hutchinson said, the thin smile returning. “I have been a leader of men for a long time, and I’ve learned that demanding results tends to produce results. I have every confidence that if I were to give you a fortnight, you would take a fortnight. I’ve chosen instead to give you five days, and I’m certain that you’ll avail yourself of that time. And if in the end I’m proved wrong…” He shrugged his narrow shoulders. “Well, we still have my solution, don’t we?”
Hutchinson picked up a piece of parchment from his desk and began to read what was written there. “That is all, Mister Kaille.”