He’d made being a professional pitcher his whole identity. He’d let it become his life, while only his music spoke the truth of who he really was. It had worked. It had contented him. But now that the pillar of his self-identity had been stripped away, he didn’t know what to do.
Maybe it was time to find something new to throw his all into.
Yeah, maybe.
Maybe that something new should be Leslie.
Peter drained his glass of orange juice and set it on the patio table next to him. Then he put his hands in the front pouch of his hoodie and stepped onto the grass, enjoying the sunshine on his shoulders. The rays were warm and gentle when he closed his eyes and turned his face toward the sun.
The sound of a door opening behind him had his eyes popping open. He swung his head around to see who it was and came face-to-face with an extremely pissed-off Mark Cutter. “You son of a bitch!”
Uh oh.
The catcher swung a fist and connected hard with Peter’s left eye, dropping him like a stone. Stars exploded behind his eyes as pain radiated from his cheekbone and he landed on his ass in the grass. He shook his head, clearing the daze, and looked up to find Mark standing over him with fisted hands and heaving chest.
“You know.” It wasn’t a question.
The catcher offered him a hand. As soon as Peter was on his feet, Mark clocked him hard again, his fist like granite. “Fuck!” That one connected with his lip, soundly splitting it and whipping his head back.
“That’s for sleeping with my sister, asshole.”
Peter swiped a hand across his split lip as emotions welled up inside him. “She slept with me too, man.”
Mark cocked his arm again, eyes hard like diamonds, and let it fly. Peter was ready this time and dodged the swing. Unwilling to let it go, the catcher dropped low and slammed a shoulder into his solar plexus, taking Peter down hard. For the next few minutes they scrapped, threw elbows, and clipped chins. The only sounds were of them grunting and swearing.
One of Mark’s elbows connected with his jaw, snapping his teeth together and making him wince. “All right, jackass. Enough.” Peter had let the catcher have at him, considering it his brotherly right, but he’d had enough now and rolled away.
He sat up just as the blond-haired ballplayer did too. They were both out of breath and just sat on the grass in silence while they tried to slow their racing hearts. Mark sat staring straight ahead at the giant oak tree by the back fence, a tick working his jaw.
Finally he said very quietly, “My sister acts tough, but she’s not. If you hurt her I’ll bust your jaw.”
Fair enough. “Deal. Although I don’t think you have anything to worry about. She threw me out the last time I was around.”
The catcher slid him a look. “Yeah?”
Peter nodded. “Yep.”
His lips twitched. “Good.”
It hadn’t felt good when she’d done it. “How’d you find out?”
Mark squinted into the sun and pulled at a few blades of grass. “Lorelei told me.”
Figured.
The two of them sat there in silence for another minute. Then Mark exhaled loudly. “Why did you do it, Pete? Couldn’t you have done your sniffing around someone else?”
That was a good question. “No, man. I couldn’t.”
Mark shot him a lethal glare. “Why the fuck not?”
Another good question. “She gets to me, dude.”
The catcher tossed the shredded blades of grass back down and bent his knee, resting his forearm on it. “Are you saying that you have feelings for her?”
There it was, the moment of truth. Did he have feelings for Leslie? “Yeah.” Deep, profound feelings that more than bordered on scary.
“She deserves someone who’ll take good care of her and treat her right.”
Peter swallowed around the sudden lump in his throat. “Yeah.”
Mark stared at him with hard gray eyes. “Is that you?”
He heard what her brother was really asking and it made his stomach squeeze. There was no turning back. Was he ready for this?
Peter met his gaze, took a deep fortifying breath. “Yeah, it is.”
“Yeah? Shit.” The catcher swore. “Then you gotta prove it, pal.”
Chapter Twenty-Six
LESLIE TOOK A break from balancing the club’s financial accounts and smothered a yawn. It was ten at night on a Tuesday, but she felt tired like it was already Friday. Leaning back in her padded leather chair, she took a good hard look around her office. From her framed pictures over the couch to her bookcases and unhappy foliage. She studied the exposed red bricks, the hardwood floor, and the piles of mail on her sleek wood desk.
This was her life.
“Oh for crissake,” she muttered and snatched up the cup of coffee in front of her. It’s not like what she had was bad. Most people would consider it a pretty sweet life. She really needed to stop feeling sorry for herself and just get over it. Get over him and move on.
It’d be a whole lot easier though if she wasn’t still in love with the jerk.
As much as she’d tried to lie to herself, her heart had known better. It had seen the truth that she was trying to hide from. Peter Kowalskin had a hold on her good, and it wasn’t going to let go any time soon. Like, never.
She was stuck with love.
Frowning, Leslie took a sip of the strong brew cut with half-and-half and considered the state of her life, trying to look on the positive side of things. So okay, she’d lost the bet and Peter wasn’t going to play in the club. That wasn’t so bad. And she didn’t get the down payment she needed to buy Mark out. Okay, fine. It just meant that it was going to take her longer to save up like she’d originally planned. It did not mean that it was over. She wasn’t a quitter.
In the meantime, she had the club to manage. And it was great, really it was, building her brother’s business. She had sunk a lot of effort into it and turned it into something good. Mark was proud of her. She was proud of her. And someday in the far-off future it would be hers to own, so none of her effort was going to waste.
Leslie had her work and her apartment and her kitten. Soon there would be a new niece or nephew to spoil too. Everything was wonderful really. Maybe not perfect, maybe things hadn’t worked out like she’d wanted, but that was okay.
She could deal with it.
And late last night she’d made a decision to stop beating herself up for her mistakes. Because the reality was that Leslie Cutter wasn’t perfect, not by a long shot. She made stupid mistakes and bad judgment calls. The bet was just one of them.
Same with falling in love with Peter. It was a dumb thing to do given who he was and she’d known it. Known it and didn’t stop it. So she had nobody to blame but herself for her current situation. But she’d learned another hard lesson and she just wanted to let it go, to chalk one up for life and just be done. It was all so wearisome, always judging herself so harshly.
And she was done being angry at Peter for lying about her apartment, for playing her. It was just who he was and she couldn’t blame him for it. All along she’d known he was a scrapper, an opportunist. Given how he’d grown up there wasn’t much chance of him being any other way. He’d learned how to work angles, how to exploit others for his own self-interest.
It had been a matter of survival.
Her heart couldn’t hold a grudge against him for that. Just like she couldn’t hold a grudge against him for not loving her back. Oh, she’d wanted to all right. At first. Man, when he’d stood in her apartment and stated that he didn’t love her with such cool, detached eyes it had taken all of her willpower not to clobber him upside the head with a frying pan. That kind of rejection stung, bad. And it had succinctly destroyed the idea she’d been growing about having her business back and Peter.