Besides, Sam was kind of cute. He looked to be around the same age as me, too. His dirty-blond hair was styled messily, and his eyes were a pretty pale blue. He wasn’t as built as Andy, but Sam’s body suited him.
“Quit staring at her like you want to lick her. It’s nasty. I’ll say it again—she’s like my sister,” Andy groaned.
“Shut it, Andy,” I scolded.
“So, are you from around here?” Sam asked.
“Nope, Andy and I moved here from California together.”
“I should have known that you’re a California girl. You just have the look. Why the hell did you move from California to West Virginia?”
I glanced at Andy. “I just needed a change, and Andy did, too. Besides, I like West Virginia. People are so nice here.”
Sam laughed. “You’re nuts, but whatever. Do you go to WVU?”
“I do. I’m a freshman.”
“I’m a sophomore.”
“Cool,” I said, unable to think of anything else to say.
I was terrible at this. It had been so long since the last time I tried to flirt that I didn’t know how anymore. This used to come so naturally to me.
“I live with a couple of guys, and we’re having a party this weekend. You should come,” Sam said.
“She’s not interested,” Andy said.
“Ignore him. I’d love to come,” I said as I glared at Andy.
“Great. Let me give you the address.”
I ignored Andy’s disapproving glare as Sam wrote down his address for me.
“Thanks!” I said.
Andy grew more and more agitated as I talked with Sam. I knew Andy was trying to protect me, but it wasn’t his job. I had to move on, and I wasn’t going to waste any time.
After about an hour, I decided that I’d stayed long enough. Andy walked outside with me to my car.
“What the hell are you doing?” he asked.
“Nothing. Why?”
“Don’t play innocent, Emma. Why did you let him think you were interested?”
“Maybe I am!”
“Bullshit. Look, I know you’re hurting, but jumping to some guy who you don’t even know will not fix things. You need to take time to heal.”
“I’m tired of being alone.”
“You’re not alone, Emma. Besides, I never took you for one of those girls who needs a guy around constantly. You’re better than that.”
“I guess I am one of those girls. I’m so sick of being alone all the time. It’s been two years, and I think it’s time that I started trying to find someone who wants me, someone who doesn’t have a kid on the way.”
“So, what are you going to do? Sleep your way through Morgantown until you don’t feel alone?”
“I never said that! Just because I want to date doesn’t mean I’m going to sleep with every guy out there!”
“You’re hurting, and you’re vulnerable. I don’t want you to do something you will regret later.”
“Like last time?”
His mouth dropped open.
I took the chance to get in my car and drive away. I hated fighting with Andy, but I didn’t need someone to tell me how to live my life. If I wanted to live like that, I would have stayed back in California with my mom.
Chapter Five: Jesse
“Hey, I’m leaving school. Is there anything that you want me to pick up for dinner?” I asked as I walked across campus.
“I don’t care as long as I get food,” Ally said on the other end of the line.
“Okay, I’ll be home in a few.”
“Love you, Jesse.”
I hesitated for a second before answering her, “I love you, too.”
I ended the call and continued to walk toward my car. It still felt strange to tell Ally that I loved her. I did love her, just not in the way that she wanted. I was trying my hardest to learn to love her, but it just wasn’t happening. I felt like a total asshole for not being able to, but it wasn’t something I could control. It was either there, or it wasn’t, and in Ally’s case, it wasn’t.
I sighed as I walked. My life was a fucking disaster. But then again, when hadn’t it been? For as long as I could remember, things were always tough—except for when I’d been with Emma. I stopped myself. There was no point in going there again. That part of my life was over, and I needed to accept it.
I continued across campus as I tried to get Emma out of my head. Since I’d been so lost in my thoughts, I glanced up to make sure I was still going in the right direction, and I stopped dead.
This is getting ridiculous.
I’d been thinking about Emma, and just now, I could have sworn I’d seen her walking a few people ahead of me. I shook my head. I needed to get my priorities straight. I had to figure out how the hell I was going to take care of Ally and a baby in a few months, not imagine that Emma was here.
The crowd of students parted, and I noticed the same girl again.
God, she looks so much like Emma.
Her hair was shorter, but other than that, she was identical from behind. Out of morbid curiosity, I followed her, keeping a few people in between us. She seemed to be headed in the same direction as me anyway. The more I stared at her, the more she reminded me of Emma. She even walked the same. She reached the parking lot before me and walked over to an SUV. Before I could stop myself, I called out Emma’s name. The girl froze for a second before turning to face me.
I nearly dropped my bag as I stared at her. It was Emma.
What the hell is she doing in West Virginia?
Unable to believe that I was really seeing her, I felt like I was in a daze as I walked slowly toward her. She stood there, frozen, as I approached. I raised my hand to touch her cheek, but she backed away.
“Emma?” I whispered.
She was really here. The girl who’d haunted my dreams for years was standing right in front of me. She had always kept her hair halfway down her back, but it was up to her shoulders now. Something else was different about her, too, but I couldn’t put my finger on it. She was still my Emma, but something had changed. It took me a moment to realize that it was her eyes. Emma had always had an open heart, and her eyes were like windows into it. Now, they were closed off, like she had built a brick wall around herself.
“You look different,” she said quietly.
I guessed I did. I’d cut my blonde hair not long after I’d moved to West Virginia. Instead of it hanging around my face, it was now only an inch or two long. In the last two years, I’d also bulked up by lifting weights. I’d needed an outlet since I couldn’t surf, and it had been my substitute. Other than that, I still looked the same. At least, I thought I did.
“It is you. Shit. What are you doing here? It’s been so long since I’ve seen you.”
“I need to go,” she said hurriedly.
Before I could stop her, she was in her car and driving away. My brain finally started functioning again, and I ran to my car. I tore out of the lot and went the same direction she had. I was afraid that I’d lost her in traffic, but I finally caught up with her about a mile down the road. I didn’t think she even realized that I was following her as she weaved in and out of the evening traffic.
She pulled up to an apartment complex, got out of her car, and ran inside. I didn’t think twice about following her as I threw my car in park and chased after her. She ran up the stairs and to the second floor with me not far behind her. She was far enough ahead of me that she managed to get inside apartment 2B just before I made it to the door. I beat on the door as I shouted her name. I had to know why she was here. There was no way that this was a coincidence.
I continued to beat my fist against the door for a good five minutes before it finally opened. I’d expected Emma, but instead, a shirtless Andy stood in the doorway.
What the fuck? Did someone throw me into the twilight zone today or what?