She was on her belly, head down into Betsy's cunt, her ass up in the air. She swayed erotically, feeling the power of lust ripple through her body, and then she felt a tingling sensation as a tongue began to ripple through her own cunt, and she knew that one of the guys, at least, was ready for some more action. She closed her eyes, trying to decide if it was Chad or Joey who was eating her out, but she realized she didn't care all that much.
"Ooohh!" she purred, recognizing the frisky tongue work of Chad. She'd been hoping for another round with him. God, she couldn't get enough of that big prick of his! Still lapping at Betsy, and rocking to the rhythm of Chad's tongue up her pussy, she looked up in time to see Joey coming around to Betsy's head. His cock was standing up nice and stiff, and Betsy smiled. Guys must really get off on watching girls go at one another. The boys had been soft as overcooked noodles a few moments ago, but the sight of Amy going down on Bets had stiffened them up pretty much.
Joey squatted above Betsy's head and pushed his cock down toward her mouth. She had her eyes shut, and she was moaning and groaning as she received Amy's hot licking, but the touch of Joey's cock on her lips made her eyes open, fast enough! She looked up, giggled, and made her lips an ovaled gateway for the boy's ready cock. He thrust down and she started to suck on him. She made slurping sounds, echoing those that came from Amy's fluttering lips.
Amy's pussy was dripping juices too, and was being invaded by Chad's tongue and fingers. He moistened his finger in her cunt and started to tickle her ass. He'd confessed that she was the girl he'd ever found that really got off on his big cock up her shithole. His finger moved in and out of Amy's asshole, and she told him with her muscles that whatever he wanted to do was simply fine and dandy as far as Amy Gibbs was concerned. She literally couldn't decide whether she preferred it up the pussy or the ass, and the only way to make up her mind was to keep on doing it both ways until she could choose.
He stuck his middle finger all the way up her ass and gave it a lusty wiggle. Amy gasped and raised her head from Betsy's cunt.
"Oh, Jesus, I love it when you do that to me!" she said hoarsely. "I fucking love it!"
"You sure don't act like the daughter of missionaries," Chad said, working his finger in and out. His tongue lapped at her swollen clit.
"Maybe you should fuck missionaries' daughters more often," Amy sighed. She looked at Betsy's flushed, excited face, and at the intense concentration Joey showed as he pushed his prick in and out of Betsy's mouth. "Oh, let's all do it together," she suggested. "Let's have a real orgy!"
Amy was the anchor. She lay on her back, legs open to let Chad between them, her pussy uplifted and resting on Chad's knee. His cock was stuffed up her asshole. She was still really tight back there, and getting him inside was a bit painful, but once he was there, she felt as if she didn't want him ever to take the fucker out!
Betsy was atop Amy, her head down between her cousin's upraised legs. She had Amy's pussy spread, and she was licking the clit and the pussy mouth, tongue flitting around like a dragonfly. Betsy's pussy was in Amy's face, and Amy was paying her cousin back, lick for lick, suck for suck. She couldn't keep away from Betsy's stiff pink clit unless it was to sample the juices that oozed from Betsy's lust-reddened pussy slice.
She had a little trouble getting at the juices, though, because Joey's cock was shoved up Betsy's cunt and moved in and out in frantic pussy-craving plunges. Amy lapped at the prick as it fucked her cousin, and she sipped Betsy's juices off its stiff barrel. Once in a while, when Joey got too excited, his cock bounced out of Betsy's cunt and Amy's mouth was there, waiting to capture it for a moment of eager sucking.
Betsy stopped laughing abruptly and looked back at Joey. He had her by the ass and he was fucking her strongly, skillfully, using his stiffness wisely.
"Oh, Joey-Blowy!" she giggled. "I been watching Chad fuck Amy's ass, and I've just gotta have some of that, too! Take your cock out of my pussy and stick it up my asshole, okay? I promise I won't cry and scream like I did the other day, honest!"
Amy giggled. Joey didn't need to be asked twice when it came to fucking a tight teen asshole! He pulled his cock out of Betsy's pussy.
"Lemme get it good and wet," Amy suggested, pulling his prick to her mouth. She took him inside and drooled hotly all over his rigid boner before releasing him. "Okay, stud, go to it!" she told the boy. "I wanna see you buried to the balls in my little blonde cousin's shithole!"
"Ohhhhh!" Betsy gurgled as Joey put his cock against the opening of her ass. He spread the cheeks, sliding his pussy-wet cockknob across her pink asshole, and then he wedged the tip into the little aperture, pushing forward until his cock crown had slithered inside. "Oh, fuckin' wow!" Betsy gasped.
Fuckin' wow, indeed! Amy thought, watching breathlessly from beneath. She lifted her lips and gave Joey's balls a little nipping squeeze. The boy yelped and thrust, and the sudden action sent his cock barreling straight into Betsy's asshole. Betsy shrieked as she was totally penetrated, and Amy gave a smug little giggle of satisfaction. She reached up and eased her finger into her cousin's cunt, much more gently than Joey's cock had slammed home, and started to work in and out in counterpoint to the thrust of Joey's aroused prick.
"Oh, shit!" Betsy whined, swaying from side to side. She dipped her face down to Amy's cunt, but she wasn't much inclined to suck pussy right now. She was getting cock up the ass, driving, hard cock, for the very first time, if you didn't count the tentative penetration Joey had made the other day.
Amy sighed, envying Betsy that wild wonderful sense of sexual discovery that a girl could know only a few times. She probed the lining of Betsy's pussy with her finger, sighing at the feel of his cock, ramming madly on the other side of the narrow wall of flesh that divided the cuntal from the ass passage. She worked her digit up and down her cousin's cunt, until Betsy was rocking like an earthquake.
Chad's prick continued to ram Amy's ass, but she was an old hand at cornholing by now. Her asshole was still supremely tight around the big invading cock, but she gave a little sigh of regret, aware that she'd never again be able to take it for the very first time.
Betsy was still too preoccupied to eat pussy, but she did have the presence of mind to put her hand on Amy's cunt, and Amy groaned, as her clit began to throb in rhythm with her fucked asshole. She was going to come, and it wouldn't take long, she was sure. And then they could fuck again!
She smelled the aroma of Betsy's ass as it was opened wide by Joey's ramming cock. Mmmm, he was used to the assfucking that Amy gave him, and he was giving it to Bets just a little roughly, considering that this was her virgin dip.
It was obvious, from the flood of pussy juices that bathed her cunt-probing finger, that Betsy was really getting into this new sex thrill.
She slurped up into Betsy's cunt, still working her finger deeper and deeper into the simmering pussy pie. She watched Joey's cock bang in and out, stretching the tight red asshole wider with each thrust. Betsy was still moaning, but she wasn't complaining now. Amy could tells from the convulsive quivers of the pussy around her finger, and from the excited bounce of her cousin's ass, that Betsy was as deep into ass fucking now as Joey's cock was in her asshole.
"Oh, baby," she kept purring, "deeper, deeper!"
Amy rocked to the attack of Chad's cock, too, eating it with her own hungry ass. She pulsated from the coaxing strokes of Betsy's fingers, that tickled her cunt and edged her closer and closer to an orgasm.