I was serving coffee to the two officers when Scott arrived a few minutes later with Georgina in tow. Literally. He held her hand and dragged her into the living room behind him. She wore a long, plush bathrobe, loosely belted, and her slippers were on the wrong feet. Her glorious hair was caught behind her head in a careless ponytail with a fat red rubber band. She looked sleepy and confused, as if she had awakened in a strange hotel room in a foreign city where everyone was speaking Hungarian. Scott led her to the chair he had recently vacated and held on to her hand until she was comfortably seated. Then he perched beside her on the arm of the chair. “Georgina, these people are from the police. They want to talk to you about Dr. Sturges.”
Georgina looked from Sergeant Williams to Officer Duvall with wide, frightened eyes. Her lips formed a tight line and she shook her head back and forth like a reluctant child.
“I’ve explained to my wife that her doctor is dead,” Scott said. “I’m afraid she’s in shock.”
Georgina stared at her hands, which were folded tightly together in her lap.
“Tell them what you told me, honey.” Scott’s voice was soft, almost a whisper. His big hand reached out to envelop hers.
Georgina glanced from my face to her husband’s and back again, as if she were watching a tennis match.
“Come on, baby.”
Georgina bowed her head and gazed up at her husband through lowered lashes. When she spoke, it was to Sergeant Williams. “I went for my regular appointment at three. It was at three, wasn’t it, honey?”
“Yes, at three. I drove you there myself.”
“I opened the door, went up the stairs, and sat down on the couch like always. But she never came.” Big tears coursed down my sister’s pale cheeks. “Diane never came.”
“Did you notice anything unusual while you were waiting for the doctor, Mrs. Cardinale?” Officer Duvall leaned forward, his elbows resting on his knees.
Georgina shook her head.
“Anybody coming or going?”
“No.”
“What did you do when the doctor didn’t show up?”
“Walked.”
“Walked? Walked where?”
Georgina raised her head. “Home, like I always do.” She glared at me as if daring me to contradict her. I was beginning to suspect she wasn’t as out of it as she seemed.
I opened my mouth to reply, then thought better of it.
“Walking relaxes her,” Scott volunteered. “Sometimes if it’s been a difficult session, she’ll call me for a pickup, but this time, she walked.”
Now Scott was lying, too. I couldn’t figure out what was going on. Why was Georgina afraid to mention that she had discovered the doctor’s body? True, we had run off without calling 911, but that wasn’t a crime. Not that I knew of, anyway. Besides, we had made that call. Eventually.
I was leaning back against the mantelpiece digesting all this when it suddenly came to me. My God! Scott must think Georgina did it!
Georgina began to sob, shoulders shaking. I reached out to smooth her hair while Scott sat silently, holding her hand in both of his. “I think my wife needs to go back to bed now, Officers. She’s on medication.”
Officer Duvall set his coffee mug down on the tray and stood up. “Fine. But we will want to talk to her again later.”
Scott led a dazed Georgina away, leaving me alone with the officers and in a fine pickle. I knew I had to say something, but was paralyzed with indecision. I had been at the scene, after all, and I hadn’t been wearing rubber gloves. It would be hard to explain away my fingerprints if I didn’t tell them what I knew about Georgina.
I began to gather up the dirty mugs.
“Here, let me help you with that.” Sergeant Williams slipped her notebook into the pocket of her blazer and picked up the tray.
“Uh, thanks.”
Sergeant Williams followed me to the kitchen. As we passed the TV room, I could hear the blare of early-morning cartoons. I peeked in. Sean and Dylan lay on my unmade bed, chins cupped in their hands, watching Spider-Man. Julie sat cross-legged on the floor, drinking juice from a sippy pack, Abigail Rabbit resting between her knees.
“The children should be getting ready for school,” I said.
“It’s Saturday,” Sergeant Williams reminded me.
I slapped my forehead with my palm. “So it is! All this has got me completely discombobulated.”
In the kitchen Sergeant Williams set the tray down next to the sink, then leaned against the counter. “I’ve been watching you,” she said, “and I have the feeling there’s something you’re wanting to tell me.”
I was dizzy with relief. “That obvious, huh?”
She nodded. “I could see the war going on all over your face.”
I paced back and forth between the stove and the refrigerator. “I don’t know quite how to put this…”
Sergeant Williams simply stared at me, breathing evenly. I watched the gold necklace she wore move slightly with each throb of the pulse at her throat. I’d read about this technique. Keep your mouth shut and the suspect will keep talking just to fill the void.
It worked. My brain churned through the silence, worrying about my sister, who appeared determined to paint herself into a corner with lies she’d never be able to explain away once the truth became known. I was little Miss Goody Two-shoes, about to spill the beans. Tough love, Hannah. You’ll have to do it.
“I’m afraid my sister didn’t tell you the full truth just now.” My stomach lurched. I paused to take a deep breath, stalling for time. I wanted to put what we had done in the best possible light. “Georgina called me from Dr. Sturges’s in hysterics,” I babbled. “When I got there, we saw Dr. Sturges lying on the rocks. I was going to dial nine-one-one, but Georgina panicked and ran away. I found her by my car. After I managed to calm her down, we called nine-one-one from a nearby pizza place.”
“What time was this?” As if she didn’t know.
“About five o’clock.”
Sergeant Williams made a notation in her notebook. “If your sister’s appointment was at three, that means she was alone in the doctor’s office for two hours.”
“It took me almost an hour to get there.”
“An hour?”
“I live in Annapolis.”
Sergeant Williams raised a suspicious eyebrow. “Why didn’t she call her husband?”
I shrugged. “He was watching the children.”
Sergeant Williams slipped her ballpoint pen into her purse. “Thank you for telling me, ma’am. I know how difficult it must be for you.”
“I honestly can’t figure out why Georgina didn’t tell you about this in the first place. She didn’t commit any crime.”
Sergeant Williams’s face gave nothing away, so what she said next took me completely by surprise. “You’re not going to like this, but we’ll need to take your sister down to the station for questioning.”
Tears pricked the corners of my eyes. “Oh, God! Please don’t tell her you learned anything from me! She’ll never forgive me.” I felt like Judas Iscariot.