Tatigan shook his head. “A small progression,” he replied. “To forge weapons of death in fires that can easily take an eye or a hand … There can be great art in savagery, I grant you, but I was speaking of poets-singers, not battle drums. A battle hymn is different from a love poem.”
“Maybe we’re not capable of poetry,” Ashok said.
Tatigan leaned back in his chair. “Not yet, perhaps,” he said. “You have no rich history to preserve in song or story. But if Ikemmu survives, your race might one day be capable of great works.”
“And if we’re not?” asked Ashok.
“You preserved Darnae’s song,” Tatigan said. “You must have seen some value in it. And anyway, she’s already declared you her hero, so how can you argue?”
“You see?” Darnae said. She grinned and poured more wine.
Ashok drank, and listened while they talked, and for the first time in his life he felt peace without fear. In Darnae’s shop, on the edge of an uncertain fate, he could be himself without fear of losing himself. He only wished the feeling could last.
CHAPTER TWENTY-TWO
When Ashok returned to Tower Athanon he intended only to rest a short while and head out again to try to visit Chanoch in the dungeons. He needed to see the young warrior, to make sure that he wasn’t suffering, and to confirm the feelings stirring in him after his conversation with Tatigan and Darnae.
Despite the halfling’s faith and Uwan’s, Ashok knew his presence in Ikemmu was a detriment to the city. If Vedoran was right, and unrest was brewing among the other religions, Ashok needed to leave before it exploded into an all out conflict.
A dark one waited outside Ashok’s room. He recognized it as the same one who’d brought him food after his nightmares.
“A message for you, come from Makthar,” the dark one said. “The cleric Natan wishes your company. If you cannot speak to him at Makthar, he will be glad to come here.”
Ashok sighed. “Tell him I’ll come to Makthar at once,” he said.
Natan received him in what Ashok thought must be the main chapel room for followers of Tempus. There were no benches, and the room was dimly lit by candles. The sword of Tempus was carved into the wall, as large and as ominous-looking as the day Ashok had first awoken in Ikemmu.
He’d woken up in a new world and emerged from that world a different being-except that he had no idea where he truly belonged. He could not go home, and he could not stay in Ikemmu under the shadow of that sword.
Natan came across the room to greet him. Ashok had expected the cleric to look well given that his sister’s safety was assured, but if anything, Natan appeared even more haggard than he’d been the last time Ashok had seen him.
A creeping fear stole over him, and Ashok blurted out, before Natan could utter any pleasantries, “What’s happened? Is she all right?”
Natan looked briefly taken aback, then his face softened, and he clasped Ashok’s arm. “I knew it was right to come to you,” he said. “Tempus forgive me-I had my doubts about you before, but no longer.”
“Tell me she’s well,” Ashok said.
“Physically, she is well,” Natan said. “In other respects, she suffers, as I’m sure you’re aware.”
“Yes,” Ashok said. “Has she spoken of her ordeal?”
“No,” Natan said, and a look of frustration crossed his face. “She has not spoken to me. She will not see me.”
“Give her time,” Ashok said. “The memories of her prison cell …” He wasn’t sure how much to say. It wasn’t his place, if Ilvani wouldn’t speak of it. “I was there, and what I saw won’t soon fade from my mind. For Ilvani, the agony is a thousand times worse.”
Natan put a hand over his eyes. “I know,” he said. “But that is just what aches. She is my sister. We are very different-she is different, as I’m sure you also know-but we could always talk to each other. When her speech didn’t make sense to anyone, I understood her.” His voice hardened. “Yet now I’m helpless. She won’t let me help her. She has sealed herself in her chamber and won’t admit anyone. I cannot”-his voice shook-“sit idle, as I have done for a month and more, while she suffers.”
Ashok stayed silent while Natan unburdened himself. When the cleric finished, he looked a hundred years old. Ashok realized then that not one but two shadar-kai had emerged from that slaughter room, and both had been deeply scarred by their experience.
“Perhaps,” Ashok said cautiously, “if only for now, you shouldn’t think of Ilvani as your sister.”
“What?” Natan looked stricken. “How else could I see her?”
“The person I took out of that cage is not the same person you knew here in Ikemmu,” Ashok said. Natan flinched, but Ashok didn’t spare him. “Ilvani suffered and was made to watch her companions be tortured to death in the most hideous ways imaginable. You and I cannot comprehend what she had to do to endure, what she had to give up of herself. Whoever she is now, she is not the sister you knew. You have to stop treating her as if she were.”
Natan was silent. The words hurt, but Ashok could see him considering them. He nodded, reluctantly, after a time, and looked up at the sword on the wall.
“Why did He give her this burden?” he asked. “What they did to her … it was not an honorable death in battle; it was a death of the mind and spirit. Why did Tempus not give her the strength to defeat her enemies?”
“This wasn’t Tempus’s doing,” Ashok said. “Mortals did this. The gods-what do they care to preserve or ruin one life? What are we to them, truly? I would be afraid if the gods took such an interest in me, for good or for evil.”
Natan looked at him in confusion. “You don’t want a god to act on your behalf, as Tempus has done?”
Ashok shook his head. “I don’t know that he’s acted for my benefit,” he said. “But if he has, I question why he took such an interest in a single life. There are bigger concerns in the world.”
“But what if a single life can change the fates of many?” Natan said, and Ashok saw some of the fire rekindled in his gaze. “Wouldn’t that be worth a god’s attention?”
“I don’t have that in me,” Ashok said. “You think too highly of me. Uwan thinks too highly of me.”
“Perhaps,” Natan said. “But you changed my sister’s fate. That’s enough to place you in my highest esteem, for the rest of my life.” He smiled faintly. “And now I’m here, asking you to help me again.”
“What do you want me to do?” Ashok said wearily.
“Speak to Ilvani for me,” Natan said.
Ashok sighed. “I don’t believe she would welcome that,” he said.
“I think you’re wrong,” Natan said. “You’ve made me see that she is in a terrible, dark place, a place where she doesn’t recognize herself, let alone the ones who care about her. Knowing that, I think of all the beings in the world, the only one she will speak to is the one who knows what it feels like in the dark. You are that person.”
“If she says no,” Ashok warned, “that’ll be the end of it. I won’t press her.”
“I understand,” Natan said. “Will you go to her now?”
Ashok shook his head. “No,” he said. “There’s something I need to do first.”
Natan started to argue but seemed to think better of it. “Chanoch,” he said.
Ashok nodded. He started to turn away, then abruptly he said, “Do you believe in forgiveness?” He kept the bitterness from his voice, but it was a struggle.
Natan smiled sadly, as if he saw every bit of Ashok’s internal struggle. “I do,” he said. “But the rule of this city is not mine. We put our lives in Uwan’s hands and must trust his judgment.”
“And Tempus’s?” Ashok asked.
“Yes,” said Natan.
“Because Tempus would never choose someone unworthy to serve Ikemmu,” Ashok said.
“Never,” Natan said. His faith restored, he put his hand on his chest and bowed his head to the sword on the wall.
When he raised his head a breath later, Ashok was on his way to the door.