Jumping to conclusions as she often did, I thought at the time, but it turned out that on this occasion she was at least half right. Something had happened to Andrew Vorhees, the kind of something that would be overheated media fodder for days to come.
We had advance word before the news became public. Tamara had texted her Hall of Justice pipeline, a woman named Felicia who worked in the SFPD’s computer section, asking for any information the Department might have on Vorhees. The answer she received prompted a furious series of back-and-forth texts to learn the details.
Vorhees was dead. Bludgeoned to death, the apparent victim of a carjacking. A patrol unit had spotted his Aston Martin speeding on Geneva Avenue near the Crocker Amazon Playground shortly after 2:00 A.M.; the driver, a nineteen-year-old youth from the projects, refused to stop and there’d been a brief high-speed chase that ended when the kid missed a turn and ran the Aston into a light pole. When the cops checked the trunk, they found Vorhees’ body stuffed inside.
The ghetto youth and his passenger cousin admitted they’d stolen the car, but swore they hadn’t committed the murder, hadn’t had any idea there was a dead man in the trunk. Their story was that they’d seen the Aston parked on a street in Visitacion Valley, the keys in the ignition, and decided to take it for a ride. The police weren’t buying. Both suspects had juvenile rap sheets for stealing and stripping cars, and though the murder weapon hadn’t been found with the body, the assumption was that the youths had tossed it and were heading somewhere to get rid of the body when they were spotted.
“Crap,” Tamara said. “Pure crap.”
“You don’t think it was a carjacking?” I asked her.
“No way.”
I didn’t think so, either, but I said, “Why not?”
“Bunch of reasons. Too big a coincidence, for one-Vorhees suddenly turning up dead so soon after his wife and just when he’s getting ready to hire us.”
“Go on.”
“Carjackers and guys that jump iron off the streets are different breeds of cat. No ’jacking on these two kids’ sheets.”
“They’re only nineteen. Maybe they decided to change their MO.”
She made a face to indicate what she thought of that explanation. “You ever hear of a ’jacker whacking a car owner with some kind of round blunt instrument? Uh-uh. Guns or knives.”
“Good point,” Runyon said, and I agreed.
Tamara said, “Then there’s the preliminary coroner’s report. Felicia says Vorhees’d been dead for hours when the body was found, maybe as many as seven or eight. No streetwise kids are gonna waste somebody, hang onto the hot car and the corpse for seven or eight hours, and then go out speeding with it on a city street.”
An even better point.
“So if it wasn’t a ’jacking,” she said, “and those dudes are telling the truth, why was Vorhees’ expensive wheels on the street in Visitacion Valley with him dead in the trunk and the keys in the ignition? So it’d get stolen, right? So whoever swiped it would get stuck with the corpse, right?”
“Assume a setup, then,” I said. “Who’s responsible?”
“Cory Beckett, who else.”
“All by herself? A woman who has a history of not dirtying her own hands?”
“I didn’t say that.”
“Who did the job, then? Frank Chaleen?”
“Sure. Got him to do Vorhees’ wife, didn’t she?”
“We don’t know that for sure. If Margaret Vorhees’ death was premeditated murder, then it was strictly for gain. Cory’s whole focus is money and power; presumably that’s why she took up with Vorhees in the first place. Why would she suddenly want him dead?”
“On account of he dumped her and she was pissed at losing her meal ticket.”
“That’s another thing we don’t know for sure, that he dumped her,” I pointed out. “Confronted her about Chaleen, yes, but that’s all.”
Runyon agreed. “Seems to me her reaction if he tried to walk away would be the opposite of violence-use every trick she knows to get him back on the hook.”
“Right. And if that didn’t work, she’d just lick her wounds and start looking for another mark. Vorhees isn’t the only wealthy yachtsman around who can be seduced and bled.”
Tamara wanted Cory Beckett to be guilty of both homicides. She said stubbornly, “Her motive doesn’t have to be revenge. Maybe offing him is what she was planning all along.”
“Same objection,” I said. “Nothing in it for her.”
“… Well, suppose Vorhees changed his will, put her in for a big slice of his estate? She’d want him dead before he could change it, right?”
“Now you’re reaching. No matter how smitten Vorhees was with her, he’d have to be a fool to change his will in her favor while he was still married or immediately after his wife’s death. Whatever else he was, he was no fool when it came to money. He’d have waited until he was married to Cory before he made her his heir, and then not until he was completely sure of her. Same reasoning if she wanted him dead: after they were married, not before.”
Tamara scowled, but she didn’t argue the point. “All right, then how about this? She found out somehow he was hiring us to investigate her and there’s something heavy in her past she’s afraid we’ll find out.”
“A skeleton she wants to keep closeted desperately enough to toss the rest of her plans and commit murder? Doesn’t seem likely. Besides, you’d have already picked up a hint if there was.”
“Not necessarily. I dug pretty deep, but I didn’t hit bottom.”
“Close to it, though. You can keep digging, but do you really believe you’ll find those kind of buried bones?”
No, she didn’t-I could see it in her expression-but she wouldn’t admit it. And she still wasn’t ready to let go of the subject. She said, “So maybe Cory didn’t have anything to do with it. Maybe Chaleen did Vorhees on his own.”
“For what reason?”
“So he could have her all to himself.”
“Blow up her plans, do both of them out of a piece of Vorhees’ money? That doesn’t wash, either.”
“He wouldn’t dare cross her,” Runyon agreed. “She’d eat him alive.”
“Okay, okay,” Tamara said grumpily. “So it wasn’t Cory and it wasn’t Chaleen. But it wasn’t any freakin’ carjacker, either.”
“Vorhees was the kind of man who made enemies,” I said. She opened her mouth, but I held up a hand before she could say anything. “I know, I know. The long arm of coincidence again.”
Runyon said, “SFPD’ll find out who did it and why. High-profile victim, high-priority investigation.”
“The kind that might just bring Cory and Chaleen down, whether or not they had anything to do with what happened last night.”
“Believe it when I see it,” Tamara said. Then she said, “Cops are bound to get around to us sooner or later. What do we tell them?”
“As much as we know to be fact,” I said. “Nothing more, nothing that crosses legal and ethical lines.”
“Otherwise we stay out of it.”
“That’s right. Even if Vorhees had signed a client’s contract, we’d have to stay out of it. The police wouldn’t give us permission for an independent investigation in a case like this.”
Tamara sighed. “Stuck in neutral again. Sometimes I wish we didn’t always have to go by the book.”
“We wouldn’t stay in business long if we didn’t.”
As expected, the media-local and national both-milked Vorhees’ murder for all it was worth. Statements from and interviews with the chief of police, union and City Hall officials; editorials on crime in the streets; rehash features on Vorhees’ scandal-ridden personal life and the recent death of his wife. I didn’t see or read any of the reportage; secondhand commentary from Tamara and Kerry was enough for me. I tend to avoid all direct contact with print and broadcast journalism, particularly where sensational crime news is concerned. Kerry says, only half kidding, that I’m an ostrich in the current events sandbox. Guilty.