She nodded. She didn’t look happy, but she looked resigned.
“You want me to go with you and make sure they understand how important it is to keep this quiet?”
She nodded with greater enthusiasm. I moved Spike back away from the door, and she followed me meekly through the opening.
I led her up to the rooms where the police were still encamped, intending to turn her over to the kindly sergeant. I wasn’t sure whether it was a good thing or a bad thing that Detective Foley and his partner were there, too.
“Can I talk to you for a minute?” Foley said, when I’d explained, as briefly as possible, why we were there. Amy seemed to have lost her voice from fright and was losing the battle not to cry.
I followed Foley out into the hall while his partner and the sergeant fetched tissues and a Diet Pepsi for Amy.
“Thank you,” Foley said. “I think. You’re sure all you did was talk her into coming here?”
“I didn’t talk her into lying, if that’s what you mean,” I said. “I have no idea if she’s telling the truth—that’s your problem.”
“You think we’re doing a bad job on this investigation?” Foley asked. “You think we need your help?”
“I have no idea—” I began.
“We may not be the NYPD, but we’re not some hick outfit,” he said. “If we don’t have something in-house, we can call on the state or the FBI. Every forensic and investigative tool available to modern American law enforcement is at our disposal. We have a dozen trained professional police officers working full time on this case. You people come out here from Hollyweird with your—”
“Foley, I only brought you a witness,” I said. “I happened to overhear her arguing with Walker, and I convinced her to come forward and tell the truth. If I hear anything else you can use, I’ll come and tell you that, too. And for your information, I don’t live in Hollywood. I came up for the weekend from Caerphilly, which in case you’ve never heard of it, makes Loudoun County look like Metropolis.”
“Just don’t bring me any more damned parrot surveillance tapes,” Foley said, as he turned on his heel and strode back into the room.
Nice to know I hadn’t single-handedly provoked his ire, I thought, as I headed for the stairs. More of a family project.
But something Foley had said stuck in my mind.
Chapter 36
“Every forensic and investigative tool available to modern American law enforcement,” I muttered.
“What’s that?”
I looked up to see that Michael had emerged from the police suite.
“Damn, what did the police want with you again?” I asked, feeling a sudden flutter of anxiety.
“Questions about Walker,” Michael said. “I gather I have you to thank for the decorative damsel whose arrival made them lose interest in me?”
“Yeah, Walker found his alibi, and I convinced her to talk to the police.”
“Thank God,” Michael said. “Of course, this means they’ll go looking for another prime suspect.”
“And looking in the wrong place, not to mention the wrong decade,” I said.
“Wrong decade?”
“Okay, this is going to sound crazy, but here goes,” I said. “Foley said something about them using every forensic and investigative tool available to modern American law enforcement. And yes, law enforcement has come a long way in the past thirty years. But even back in 1972, they didn’t do too shabby a job on forensics, right?”
“At least in the big cities, where they had money to get the right equipment,” Michael said, nodding.
“Yes, places like Los Angeles and San Francisco, where Ichabod Dilley hung out,” I said. “But Ichabod Dilley didn’t die in California, where the case would get decent police scrutiny. He died in a small Mexican town where the PI his family hired to investigate thought the authorities had been bribed to conceal something.”
“Like what?”
“Suicide or murder—the story doesn’t say which,” I said, with a shrug. “And possible motivation for either; he owed a lot of money to the wrong people.”
“Which is a lovely bit of Porfirian history, but how does it relate to the QB’s murder?” Michael asked.
“One of the few people who knew Dilley back in those days has just been murdered,” I said.
It sounded pretty weak when I said it aloud.
“Two murders, thirty years apart?” Michael said.
“And the second murder happened at a time when several of the people who knew Dilley happened to be around,” I said. “Nate. Maggie. Francis, if he was stretching the truth a bit about when he’d represented the QB. Which wouldn’t surprise me. If he knew something fishy had gone on back in 1972, wouldn’t he try to hide the fact that he’d known her back then?”
“In a heartbeat,” Michael said. “Right now, he’s so freaked at having his clients turn into murder suspects that I suspect he’d try to hide his connection to me and Walker if he thought he could get away with it.”
“Of course, they’re all hiding things, or at least leaving out things, fairly crucial things,” I said. “And if you call them on it, they shrug and confess, like children caught in a minor fib. As if it didn’t really matter. Or is that only another layer of deception?”
“What do you expect?” Michael said, looking suddenly tired. “It’s a habit a lot of people pick up when they’ve been working too long in an industry that cares too much about youth. So you don’t mention everything you’ve seen or done, or everyone you know, because sooner or later, someone will do the arithmetic and realize that you’ve been around a little too long. Hell, yesterday Walker asked me to stop mentioning how long ago we were in the soaps together. And it’s not as if we’re geezers or anything.”
No, but the closer Michael got to forty, the less he liked big birthday celebrations. I wondered suddenly if some kind of male biological clock thing was behind his ever-increasing desire to discuss the M word, as we called it. I’d have to think about that.
Later. When I didn’t have murder on my mind.
“Yeah, maybe that’s an explanation for how Nate, Maggie, and Francis have been acting,” I said. “But maybe one of them had something much more serious to hide than an inconveniently distant birth date.”
“Such as?”
“I can think of two theories, actually. First, one of them killed Ichabod Dilley, and the QB knew about it, and was threatening to expose them.”
“After thirty years?” Michael said.
“There’s no statute of limitations on murder,” I pointed out.
“Yeah, but why wait that long? Are you suggesting that the killer meekly endured the QB’s blackmail all these years, only to lose his or her temper and bump her off this weekend?”
“Okay, maybe that’s a little far-fetched, but what if the QB, after concealing her knowledge all these years, finally revealed it, only to have the killer strike her down?”
Michael nodded slowly.
“A little more plausible,” he said. “I like the picture of the QB like a spider on her web, sitting on her secret for decades until just the right moment to use it. Yes, she’d play it that way. Only…”
“Only what?”
“Maybe a tad too melodramatic?”
“Yeah,” I said, reluctantly. “A little too much like one of Nate’s scripts, maybe. But I have another theory.”
“I never doubted you would.”
“What if the QB herself was the murderer?”
“Of Dilley, you mean?”
“Right,” I said. The more I thought about it, the more I liked this theory. “I can imagine her killing someone who stood in her way. And maybe she didn’t even have to do the deed herself—maybe all she had to do was set him up for the guys who were after him?”