"What are you doing?"
She jumped, throwing the notebook she was reading into the air. Her mouth opened to explain, then closed. Opened again. No sound came. When she was upset, she couldn't say a thing. She tried gathering the offending materials with trembling hands, but they came in too many shapes, they scattered under her awkward clutchings. Defeated, she let them fall, closed her eyes, covered her face with her hands. She reminded me of Caitlin, who thought we couldn't see her if she couldn't see us. "Don't hate me," she said.
"Why, Claire? I would have shown you if you had asked."
I started to collect the notebooks, rice paper bound in string, Italian marbleized notebooks, Amsterdam school copybooks, smooth-bound, leather-bound, tied with shoelaces. My mother's journals, my absence written in the margins. None of this was about me. Even the letters. Only her.
"I was depressed. You were gone. She seemed so strong."
She was looking for a role model? I almost had to laugh. Claire admiring my mother made me want to slap her. Wake up! I wanted to scream. Ingrid Magnussen could damage you just passing by on the way to the bathroom.
And now she'd read the letters. She knew that I'd refused to discuss her with my mother. I imagined how it must have hurt her. Now I wished I'd thrown them out, not lugged them around like a curse. Ingrid Magnussen. How could I explain? I didn't want my mother to know about you, Claire. You're the one good thing that ever happened to me. I didn't want to take any chances. How my mother would hate you. She doesn't want me to be happy, Claire. She liked it that I hated Marvel. It made her feel close to me. An artist doesn't need to be happy, she said. If I were happy, I wouldn't need her, she meant. I might forget her. And she was right. I just might.
She scolded me in those letters. What do I care about a 98 on a spelling test? Your flower garden. You're so boring, I don't even recognize you. Who are these people you're living with now? What are you really thinking? But I never told her a thing.
"You want to know about my mother?" I took a gray ribboned notebook, opened it, and handed it to Claire. "Here. Read it."
She took her hands down, her eyes puffy and red, her nose running. She hiccupped and took it from me. I didn't have to look over her shoulder. I knew what it said.
Spread a malicious rumor.
Let a beloved old person's dog out of the yard.
Suggest suicide to a severely depressed person.
"What is this?" she asked.
Tell a child it isn't very attractive or bright.
Put Drano in glassine folded papers and leave them on street-corners.
Throw handfuls of useless foreign coins into a beggar's cup, and make sure they thank you profusely. "God bless you, miss.
"It's not real, though," Claire said. "It's not like she actually does these things."
I only shrugged. How could Claire understand a woman like my mother? She would write these lists for hours, laughing until tears flowed.
Claire looked at me hungrily, pleading. How could I stay angry with her? My mother had no idea what my favorite food was, where I'd live if I could live anywhere in the world. Claire was the one who discovered me. She knew I'd want to live in Big Sur, in a cabin with a woodstove and a spring, that I liked green apple soap, that Boris Godunov was my favorite opera, that I was afraid of milk. She helped me pack the papers back into the box, shut it, and put it under the bed.
18
RON AND CLAIRE were fighting again in their room. I could hear it as I lay in my bed, the rabbit crouching on my wall, his ears erect and trembling. Claire wanted Ron to quit his job, find something to do that didn't involve cattle mutilations or witchcraft in the Pueblos.
"What do you want me to do, wash dishes?" It was rare to hear Ron raise his voice. But he was tired, just back from Russia, he hadn't expected a fight. Usually it was a home-cooked meal and kisses and clean sheets. "I'm earning a living. It's just a job, Claire. Jesus, sometimes I just don't know what goes on in your head."
But it was a lie. What Ron did was peddle fear. There was quite a market, it seemed. Everywhere, people were frightened. Threatening shapes lurked at the edges of vision, in the next car, at the ATM, maybe waiting for them in the hall with a .38. There was poison in supermarket toothpaste. Ebola, hepatitis C. Husbands disappeared on the way to the liquor store. Children showed up dead in ditches without their hands. The picture was pulled away from the frame, the outlines were gone. People wanted monsters and ghosts and voices from beyond the grave. Something foreign, intentional, not senseless and familiar as a kid getting shot for his leather jacket.
That's what Ron supplied. Fear in a frame. Aliens are always preferable to confused, violent acts. It was a career steeped in cynicism, pumped through with hypocrisy.
Her voice in reply was like bending sheet metal.
But I could understand him word for word. "What, you think I come off a fourteen-hour day, jetlagged, at some spoonbending convention in Yakutsk, ready to party? Hey, wow, bring on the bimbos! Maybe you should try getting some work, and remember what it's like to be wiped out at the end of a day."
I felt his words burn her flesh like a lash. I tried to hear what she was saying, but her voice faded to a murmur. Claire couldn't defend herself, she curled up like a leaf under a glass.
"Astrid doesn't need you waiting with the milk and the cookies. Jesus, Claire! She's a young woman. I think she 'd like spending a few hours by herself. Maybe make some friends of her own if you'd give her a chance."
But I did need her, Ron. Nobody ever waited for me when I got home from school — and never milk. He didn't even know that much. I mattered to her. Couldn't he understand what that meant to me, and to her? If he cared, he would never say such things to her. How dare he pretend that he loved her. I cracked open my door to see if I could hear her, but she must have been whispering.
"Of course they stopped calling. Gloria said she called and called and you never picked up. Of course they gave up."
Now all I could hear was her crying. She cried the way children do, sobbing, hiccupping, nose running. And the soothing tones of his voice.
I could picture him, taking her in his arms, rocking her against his chest, stroking her hair, and she'd let him, that was the worst part of it. And they'd make love, and she'd fall asleep, thinking he was so kind, after all, he must love her. It would be all better. That was how he did it. Hurt her, and then made it all better. I hated him. He came home, upset her, when he was just going to leave her again.